Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Who fucking wrote this? (Score 1) 594

So? The Wright brothers weren't trying to achieve that. They had plenty of much more reasonable goals to achieve instead.

And, you know, we've been going to space for over half a century. We're not exactly at the Wright brothers state of experimentation any more. If you built a Wright flyer today, you wouldn't go around saying "Yes but think how much we can learn from it!"

Comment Re:Well (Score 1) 594

True, but the Wright Flyer couldn't be used for a lot of things either nor could Goddard's rockets reach space; but they were important first steps. Aviation is built on incremental steps and who knows where SpaceShip Two will lead? I have no idea where it will go but that is no reason not to try and see.

We took those first steps over half a century ago. If you'r building a Wright Flyer TODAY, you're not going to be learning much, are you?

So? Many early flights were for thrills (and money) as well. By your logic, Lindbergh's flight was just for thrills since we already knew how to reach France by boat.

"By my logic" nothing. What I am actually saying that if we had jets crossing the Atlantic already, then yes, Lindbergh's flight would be just for thrills and we wouldn't learn a damn thing from it.

Comment Re: Well (Score 1, Insightful) 594

I trust that makes the point rather well.

It does not, at all. It's not like we're struggling to reach space now. We have spacecraft. We know how to make them. We're working on making them better. They are not novel, and they are not waiting to be discovered by random chance.

The SpaceCraftTwo has very little bearing on any of that work. It's a design that can't reach orbit, no matter how hard you try. There are much more fruitful avenues to pursue if you want to improve spaceflight.

Comment Re:Well (Score 0) 594

Can, maybe. But if you're actually trying to make another kind of craft, you should be experimenting on that, not a completely different kind and hoping that maybe by chance you'll find something useful.

Comment Re:Well (Score 2) 594

The underlying technologies of the SpaceCraftTwo are completely and woefully underdimensioned for actually reaching orbit. It's just not feasible to develop it into a craft that can do that. You need a completely different solution to do it.

Slashdot Top Deals

Administration: An ingenious abstraction in politics, designed to receive the kicks and cuffs due to the premier or president. -- Ambrose Bierce

Working...