Comment Re:Which alternative exists? (Score 0) 34
Sorry to have taken you seriously, carry on.
That may be a matter of opinion and perspective as well.
Those are late compositions in Greek and clearly not part of the original Hebrew Bible (properly called the Tanakh.)
The books you mention, along with the so-called New Testament books, both those declared 'canonical' by the Imperial Roman authorities and the other books that were banned instead, along with the Talmud, are all in my mind defensible and even in cases valuable, as Midrash, as Commentary, as a record of what men at the time thought on some important subjects - but NOT as scripture to be elevated to stand with the Tanakh, let alone to actually be set ON TOP of the Bible proper as so many do.
I don't want to be young again, I just don't want to get any older.