Comment Re:Never heard that one before (Score 1) 504
Agreed, he sounds only vaguely like a *real* Jamaican accent. However, he sounds very much like a *stereotypical* Jamaican accent.
You may as well say that styling a character on traditional blackface comedy isn't racist, because blackface comedy wasn't actually a reflection of real black people. No, it wasn't - that's the entire reason it's so racist. If you're actually accurately representing a subclass of people then the potential for racism is limited - you may laugh at the otherness a bit, but it's by grossly exaggerating the differences into an insulting caricature that you create something deeply offensive. And once that caricature is established in the culture as a stereotype, a non-verbal insult, simply removing the most obvious reference to its racial roots doesn't eliminate the racism. The caricature stands on its own, invoking the mentality that created it to all who recognize it.
And incidentally, I seem to recall a number of prominent native Jamaican media personalities complaining about Jar Jar at the time - and frankly, if there's anyone fit to recognize a racist caricature, I'd say it's the targets - people who have lived their lives on the receiving end of those thinly-veiled insults. Perhaps they may be over-sensitive, but that same sensitivity also highlights in glaring relief the commoditized racism that people who have never been targeted may overlook entirely. (I grew up in a heavily Hispanic community, and to this day being called "white boy" or "gringo" will raise my hackles, even in the most friendly of contexts - and I have the benefit of being on the "winning" side of racial conflict, so the name really only brands me as "other", not "lesser")
The thing is, you don't have to intend for a racist slur to be insulting for it to be so - the insult has been baked into the slur by decades of abuse. Just as saying "red" invokes a mental impression of a certain color to anyone with color vision, so saying "nigger" invokes a mental impression of a judgment of subhuman worth to anyone familiar with the words recent history. And invoking a racist caricature does the same to anyone who has been sensitized to that caricature, even if it's done by a nonhuman CG character.