Comment 2GB? (Score 1) 827
What I don't get about the new MacBook Air is the default 2GB of memory. When every $500 PC at Best Buy is shipping with 4GB, you need to make it standard. We're spending $1000 on a MacBook Air, so it's silly to cheap out on the memory. Yeah, you can upgrade to 4GB for another $100. But you shouldn't need to special-order to get what should be the standard.
Core 2 Duo is disappointing but not unexpected. NVIDIA's chipset doesn't work with Nehalem and probably never will.
SSD is nice, but we'll have to see what the performance is. Depending on the controller it could range from poor to excellent.
Honestly, Apple did what they could. If you need to buy now, both of the MacBook Air models are nice - if expensive - machines. Getting a 1.6GHz Core 2 Duo and decent graphics in a 2.3lb package is really cool. Paying $1400 to get the configuration that this machine should have as stock (1.6GHz, 4GB, 128GB) is less so, but compared to other premium machines (ThinkPad X201s, Vaio Z) you're not paying much of a premium - you're just trading less performance for less size/weight.
The problem is that this category is about to be redefined. AMD is releasing Ontario and Zacate early next year, which will contain an out-of-order processor with similar performance to the Core 2 Duo in the Air, plus a Radeon 5400-class GPU that will handily beat the GeForce 320M in the Air. All of this in 9/18W (less than the Air) and a single chip, at a low price.
Intel is releasing Sandy Bridge next year. It will have similar graphics performance to the GeForce 320M, plus CPU performance that will blow it away. All while using less power, in a single chip.
You can already buy 11.6" notebooks with better CPU performance than the Air. The Acer 1830 series runs around $700 with an i5 and 4GB of DDR3. It has the same resolution screen as the 11.6" Air. It has a hard drive, which increases the size and weight. It also enables you to have 500GB of storage or to upgrade to a fast SSD (Intel, SandForce, etc.) for around $200. The Acer also has Gigabit Ethernet and an HDMI port.
The Air's advantage is that it's built better (aluminum vs plastic), that it's thinner/lighter (2.3lbs instead of ~3lbs), and that it runs OS X. But I can't help but think that the Mac would be better off with an i5 instead. Most people are not going to play games on an 11.6" notebook, both because of thermal issues (25W+ of CPU+GPU in that form factor means lots of heat/noise) and because PC gaming isn't that popular in general. I think most people would trade a slower Intel GPU for a faster CPU, and the Air could easily take a ULV Core i5 or i7 (18W).
Ultimately, Sandy Bridge or Zacate is the answer to this category, not a last-gen Core CPU. Apple made compromises that are acceptable but not ideal. Unfortunately, that's hard to swallow in a $1000+ machine.