Comment Re:Why we have a 5th Amendment (Score 1) 871
I'm not saying there's not an ulterior motive by the question, but then again I don't honestly believe that cops are out to get me. Are they trying to trick the unwary into admitting to possession of illegal items? Perhaps, and maybe with stupid people (those with the said illegal items) will actually answer. I have no such guilt and therefore answer honestly, and it has paid off in the two times I got stopped in the last 15 years. I got a warning, a thank-you for my honesty, and sent on my way in less than 10 minutes. Both times were Florida State Troopers, if it matters.
However, coercion is a specific word. It's a way to spin things to make the cops look bad, and it's the wrong term. Cops holding a gun and the power to arrest is an implict threat, yes, but then so is the fact I could have a hidden weapon under my seat and be a psycopathic serial killer. Regardless, don't let the logical fallacy steer you away from the discussion. You have the right not to answer, so don't, if it suits you. It hasn't suited me and I have experience to back up my judgment of being helpful to the police. Rather than being helpful, people in this thread are advocating being a dick and a complete and utter asshole, going so far as to cover up for criminals. See someone get murdered in front of you? Keep it to yourself. I mean, WTF? Seriously? If one of my kids got murdered in the street, I would hope that anyone who saw something with speak up. Wouldn't you?