My wife thinks I'm crazy, but I've bought into needing the proper shoes for the proper occasion, and having quality shoes that will last me. That includes needing to maintain a rotation to control moisture and thus the longevity of the leather. I pay more, but they'll last ten years, not one.
The below isn't an advertisement for Allen Edmonds, they just happen to be the lowest price maker of "good" shoes that also happen to carry widths. As such, I do have a bit of brand-loyalty. That said, I'm tempted to snag a few pairs of shoes from Alden shoes, maybe an Indy Boot or Chukka.
My collection:
- Walnut semi-brogues (AE Strand) - I wear these with jeans.
- Brown Chelsea "Dealer" boot (AE Ashbury) - also with jeans
- Black oxfords (AE Park Ave) - suits and tuxedo /w good shine
- Brown derbys - cheap brown derbys from JCP, still wearing until they wear out, which won't be long...
- Boat shoes - never with socks
I should probably own some sneakers for the gym... maybe, then, I'd have one less excuse.