Comment Re:Ledger for Best Supporting Actor (Score 1) 317
Rubbish.
When I went to see the film Batman, I was extremely impressed by the performance of the Joker and:
1- Had no idea who the actor was
2- Had no idea he had died.
Had anyone suggested he would win the Oscar - I would have replied: Great! Whoever that guy is - he is absolutely brilliant!
The other actors however paled before him. He did steal the show.
But the problem is that once he died, opinions got divided. People who haven't seen the film went to see it now with very critical pendantic eyes. Looking for - or imagining any - flaw. It's a bit like it's hard to have an unbiased jury if the accused has an article about him written in the press. Or finding a woman of another race attractive when you are racist. Or acknowledging Hitler's watercolours were incredibly beautiful
So his acting was hyped.
Making it harder to be objective.
Heath is an actor's actor. If you ever trained yourself to be one, you would appreciate the incredible talent.
But if you try to find any fault - because of some emotional bias - well you will find many.
I have a feeling that most people that think his acting was over-rated or bad, would have a second more honest / sombre opinion had he: not been famous or dead.