Comment Re:Repeal the law! (Score 2, Interesting) 149
Don't believe the narrative being peddled here!!
What is really happening is that the "Liberal" government of Canada got caught trying to scam Meta and Google into paying a huge amount of money to the government's favourite news outlets. You know, the ones that only report on stories that make the government look good!
Background:
The fact is that most "news organizations" benefit in one important way from the platforms built by Meta and Google, in that platforms used to directly and indirectly provide exposure to those news organizations by allowing posts of links to those news sites by their customers or by third party or platform-provided news aggregators. So in this way, the benefit of the platforms to the news organizations is positive and it makes no sense to "charge" the platform for posting news links. Indeed, there are multiple "news organizations" that have stated they will go under if the platforms start blocking the posting of their links.
The problem is that there IS an area where the platforms have caused severe cash flow problems for the news organizations, and that area is advertising. Advertisers see little benefit in paying news organizations for posting ads when the platforms can provide them with much better exposure for their ads. Historically, the news organizations have been funded by their advertising, and the new reality is that particular financial model no longer works for them. Revenue from advertising has dried up and the platforms are happily eating the news organizations' lunches.
So, just like a buggy whip company demanding government assistance when everybody drives cars, the news organizations are desperate to find a new revenue source. Somehow the LPC government has decided that they can go after the platforms on behalf of the news organizations in exchange for positive coverage from those news organizations. (Oops, was I not supposed to say that part out loud?) The only reason we're hearing whining from the LPC talking heads about "stealing" and "paying their fair share" is because the LPC has learned that if you tell a lie loud enough and often enough, it eventually starts to be believed.
What's happened here is that the strategy to shake down the platforms for money has failed as they are not willing to play ball. Now the LPC government looks like the incompetent grifters they are, as the platforms simply (and rightly!) refuse to pay the extortion fees.
Bottom line is that the news organizations need to understand that the old business model is gone and is not coming back, and trying to lobby the government to keep them afloat is reprehensible and will never work.
What this means:
So how does that relate to what is happening here?
This is all smoke and mirrors to cover up the grift of the JustInept Tru-D'OH government.
1) JustInept is implying that Canadians are so stupid that they can't get their news from any site except Google or Facebook. This is the sort of contempt for Canadians that this government holds for its own citizens.
2) JustInept thinks that he can keep screaming about how the platforms are "bad" and don't "pay their fair share" and instead of the government actually effectively communicating directly with the citizens, it's somehow the fault of Meta and Google that the government can't effectively communicate.
3) Nobody likes the platforms or thinks that they have the best interests of their users at heart, But, in THIS case, they are not the villains