Comment Re:Ineffective advertising (Score 1) 149
I thought of the Mac Pro when I saw this design, and thought "this is more what the Mac Pro should have been". Maybe not from the aesthetic perspective (maybe a bigger trash can than the current model?), but the things this system can do are far more akin to what the old cheese grater Mac Pros could do:
- accept GPU cards of the maker you choose, and upgrade them as new models come out. Or, more accurately, more PCI devices.
- accept more storage devices in the bays, or a mix of SSD and disk technologies to give a price/performance mix for people who need it.
The new Mac Pro's exterior and technological designs have a lot of high points. What is misses was that the people who were shelling out the money for the "Pro" model were probably populating a lot of the drive bays, maxing out the RAM, adding additional GPUs and making use of the dual processors or putting in add-in cards that connected to storage or other specialized equipment. They might also be upgrading the GPUs during the 3-4 years they held onto the machine, as the GPU power has been appreciating pretty quickly.
So the new model misses the use case that those people had and replaces it with a throwaway all-in-one box whose only expansion potential skips the PCI bus and takes it down several speed steps to the Thunderbolt devices that you string together like Christmas lights with wall warts, which is going to turn into a dusty rat's nest of cables. I suspect PCs like this one might be appealing to the people who bought the cheese graters.
The only major complaint I had about the cheese grater was that you couldn't put in a 19" rack without resorting to the use of a saw to hack off the handles. We have several of them in our test lab and I was hoping to consolidate them from shelves into a rack so they would look nicer and be easier to maintain but it was kind of a pain in the rear. I'd have been perfectly happy if they had not gone with the trash can design and just come up with a new motherboard that supported newer Xeon processors, had PCI 3 and the latest SATA speeds (which we get all day long for our Windows and Linux servers -- using the same hardware!), but instead we get the trash can.
Or just bring back the freaking XServe.