Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:I never realized how bad it was (Score 1) 131

Because getting flooded every few years is an even bigger hassle? Because they live near to the good crop land which they also have to go to and from every day? Because having all the people and their animals near is makes the water not clean? Because real estate is more expensive near the water?

I have no idea. But I'm sure there's a reason...

Comment Re:stopping who? (Score 1) 322

The goal of prohibition was to reduce domestic violence.
It did, it reduced it to almost 0%. It was repealed to make up for the loss in taxes from the great depression, not because it didn't accomplish it's goals.
AS a side benefit, suicides were cut in half. This is all trivial too look up.

You are right it is trivial to look up. Suicide rates for the time of prohibition, 1920 - 1933:
1920: 10.2
1921: 12.4
1922: 11.7
1923: 11.5
1924: 11.9
1925: 12.0
1926: 12.6
1927: 13.2
1928: 13.5
1929: 13.9
1930: 15.6
1931: 16.8
1932: 17.4
1933: 15.9

So I guess before prohibition you are claiming suicide rates were in the 20 - 35 range, so let's look at a few years of them:
1919: 11.5
1918: 12.3
1917: 13.0
1916: 13.7
1915: 16.2
1914: 16.1
1913: 15.4
1912: 15.6
1911: 16.0
1910: 15.3

Mmmm, nothing like double what it was in the time of prohibition. So you lied. About something you even stated was trivial to look up.

In fact prohibition seems to coincide with an end of a dramatic trend down in suicide rates replacing it with an upward trend.

My source is the "Sixteenth Census of the United States: 1940. Vital statistics rates in the United States, 1900-1940" from 1943. Relevant table runs from page 210 through to 242.

Given you clearly just made stuff up about the thing you said as "trivial too look up" why would anyone bother even reading any of your other claims?

Slashdot Top Deals

Are you having fun yet?

Working...