It's this kind of pseudo-interpretation of the law that kills any kind of validity in your arguments about anything related to this matter. It's not about what there doing, it's about what there NOT doing. One of the reasons they are being prosecuted is the fact that they are NOT filtering out illegal torrents (ohh sorry, the torrent file is legal, but the content it's pointing at is not). They go as far as giving you tools to make this easier, like categories and stuff. Sure there can be legal movies, games, pc apps, console stuff and so on and so forth. But now we're back at the filtering again, they do NOT filter out the illegal torrents (lets just call em' that). The fact that they portray the site as a piracy torrent index by, for instance, giving the finger to any one who tries to reason with them, are not helping them.

I don't get it...

Programming in python and ruby, or snowboarding and skiing ?