Comment Re:That's what abortions are for ... (Score 1) 194
You know that it usually takes 18 months after birth for a child to recognize itself in a mirror and before that they just assume it's another person in the mirror. Can you prove to me that an infant is self aware, because that would be pretty impressive. By your logic it seems like one should be able to abort their child in the first year and a half after birth.
I've mentioned this before in other contexts, and people get all in a jam about it. If, for example, someone is so brain-damaged that they no longer have a sense of self, a sense of others, etc., it doesn't really matter if they can do some sort of somnambulistic imitation of "someone being home" - there's no person, so why not just pull the plug.
I don't know that it's a full year and a half - animals (dogs and cats) catch on quite quickly that the "other" is really them, and ISTR playing peek-a-boo with my daughters via a mirror before 6 months, so they certainly understood that even a reversed image was the same person, and they didn't try to play the game with themselves
I think they pick up cues from the eye motion. It would make sense, since there are mirror surfaces in nature (water surfaces, for example), and it would be in every species' interest to be able to discount their own reflection when looking down (unable to see attackers directly). cf Aesop's Fable about the wolf crossing the stream with a chunk of meat in his mouth - pure fiction. No way is a wolf going to drop a chunk of meat for an image of one.
It IS a valid point. Would be fun to do experiments (then again, playing with your own kids is usually fun - its' OTHER peoples' kids who are the whiney, noisy, spoiled brats.