Comment Copyrights != Patents (Score 3, Informative) 199
IAAL...
Copyrights are not patents, copyrights have independent creation exception, but there's no exclusive use and you can't just point to prior art. So you can't say: look it existed before and walk away if you're sued. All musicians say I didn't steal that melody, I come up with myself! The fight always centers around: Did you actually come up with it yourself or did you hear some other song and copy it. George Harrison vs. The Chiffons being a fine example.
Despite there being an alleged hard drive with every melody possible--that's still the exact same case. Now a defendant could say: I heard it on track 512,010,120 on this copyrighted hard drive that no one has heard of or listened to vs. on that song that there's a record of me listening to on Amazon or that was played on the radio.
I'm against imaginary property as the rest of the pitchfork bearing folk but I'm not sure what the point of this was and they should get off my lawn and news feed. Good publicity for