California's high-speed rail is first-class HSR, using normal HSR trains from Siemens, and it has a good alignment that directly connects multiple population centers. There are many ways you can criticize CAHSR, but it's definitely HSR.
The problem with CAHSR, to be fair, is that they bit off a huge megaproject all at once, without a clear funding path. Argument 1 is that they should have started by building a single link between two biggest cities, like the French advised them to do at the beginning, then built it out from there.
The counter Argument 2 is that there are already rail links between those two cities, the land and existing infrastructure problems between those two cities are by far the hardest of the entire alignment, plus, the real problem in California is they need to provide alternatives to I-5, which is a traffic crisis impacting a lot of the state. Also, the marginal benefits per dollar go up the more cities you connect due to network effects. So, like it or not, California voters approved CAHSR only under the condition that it connect the major CA cities in the central valley and provide an alternative to I-5. When it's built, it will be brilliant. But they didn't go about it in the "how to show earliest results possible" way. The built in the "what makes the most long-term sense for the state" way.
It's a really good megaproject. It's main problem is that until now, it hasn't had megaproject funding. The election of Trump counter-intuitively gave CAHSR a huge tailwind. For one thing, they stopped even asking for federal money, and have opened up other funding sources to keep construction going. For another, they are in way too deep to stop it now. They have no choice but to complete at least the initial operating segment.
As of mid-2025 official CAHSR report
Structures: 55 complete (60%), 32 underway, 5 not started.
Guideway: 72 miles complete (61%), 28 underway, 19 not started.
Right-of-way parcels: 99% delivered overall for CP1–CP4 (2,276 of 2,294).
463 miles of the entire 494-mile Phase 1 SF–Anaheim system are environmentally cleared (construction-ready).