
Journal Journal: Elitism
As part of the 'Open Source', 'Slashdot', 'Linux' or what ever community we think of ourselves as being a part of, we need to be very careful to avoid elitism.
It's very easy to fall into the trap. We're the underdogs, the oppressed masses. It's certainly how many of us like to see ourselves (c'mon, be honest). The community has worked hard to achieve some amazing things, and those that oppose us, who would try to undermine what we have achieved, make themselves our enemy. We feel justified in our anger.
We can't let ourselves see oppression everywhere we look though. We can't simply lable things that at first sight seems wrong, as evil.
There was a story a while back, about using a device so that a childs location could be tracked and a parent could be confident that the child had got to school without being kidnapped or something. Well, I got on my high horse and made a posting about how wrong such technology was as it violated trust etc. etc. But thinking about it now, I was being everything I hate. opposing certain applications of technology. Given the technology, people should be free to develop and use it in anyway they see fit. I still don't like the idea of the suggested use of the device from the story, but the issue I would have is with the parents that actually abused the device, not the people who developed it. If we start labeling things as evil, then we start to hinder progress which makes us just as bad as those who we think of as our enemies.
I was reading the recent post about cameras reading number plates in Florida. At first sight, it does seem a little 1984-esq, but these are cameras in public places, the number plates of these cars are on display to the public. All that is happening is that freely available information is being collected. I really can't think of a good argument for why this is wrong, although my first instinct would have been to lable this (in my head at least) as an evil policy.
We are part of a community that has found an alternative to the current capitalism driven IT solutions, and we're shouting loudly to make the world understand that our way works, that it is viable. It's all to easy to shout just as loud about other things before we have properly considered them, we run the risk of undermining our own credability.