Journal Journal: Book Recommendations
Okay, so no one reads this but ranting is good for the soul. My complaint is picky and stupid, but I've had an experience like the situation that's bothering me so.... I've also had the kind of week that makes a person cranky.
In a recent Ask Slashdot, the questioner asked for recommendations on a scifi-geek-hacker novel for a bit of summer reading. In no time at all there are all these damned comments that get modded up as insightful because someone felt elitist and used the old line about "expanding horizons."
Damnit, no one SAID it was all he ever read. He said it was what he was looking for. I've had more people do this to me before and I really just can't stand it. The genre I read depends on the mood I'm in and when I feel like reading science fiction and I ask for recommendations in that vein, I don't appreciate getting a lecture on broadening my horizons. If I were to ask for science fiction/hacker recommendations, I would consider asking Slashdot. There is an audience here that would seem to be receptive to that genre and therefore be a place to get a few ideas of what might be worth my time. This is no way, shape, form or fashion means that it's all I ever read. It's just that if I want recommendations on a random "classic" or NYT bestseller, I've got other places I can look for reviews and suggestions.
Like I said, I've had this happen to me, including a fairly recent encounter. Late night in the CS lab near the end of the semester, I start chatting with a few people and ask for some recommendations for some science fiction summer reading and some holier-than-thou person gives me a lecture about narrow minded tastes. It was annoying as hell and would have been insulting if I hadn't shrugged the person off for being the ignorant elitist she was. I had a list of books I was already planning to read for that summer (I always have a list of books lined up to read, when it gets too short, I usually ask people I know for suggestions to add to it). As I recall it included some biographies (mostly political figures), some Molly Ivins (politics/humor), a lot of children's literature, a Spanish play (untranslated), a Garrison Keillor novel, a novel by a Croation writer (Slavenka Drakulic) and Austen's Mansfield Park. There might have been a fantasy novel in with the children's lit, but I'm not sure.
In reality, I've read less science fiction than most other genres. If you want to lump all children's literature into one genre, then that's where I've done the most reading since I still head for the juvenile section even now (not just Harry Potter--I'm a fan of a lot of kids lit. Some of the Newberry winners and medalists are among the best books I've ever read).
So there's my rant. Obviously, this is less about the Slashdot posting and more about the event in my own past that it dredged up. If I hadn't dealt with this before, then I think I would have shrugged off those highly moderated comments like I do those comments about how "much better my life has been since I sold my television" when there's an article about cable/a tv program/Tivo/whatever. Those used to bother me as well, until I realized that they must have been more addicted to TV before they quit than I am. My TV broke and I experienced no change--good or bad--in the quality of my life during the time it was down. Likewise I experienced no change when I got it back. Okay, so I'll admit it, I did kinda missed Farscape when the TV was out, but I wasn't in panic mode.
All these people that talk about how much more they get done and how they spend all this wonderful time outside, or started spending time with their families--like it's all new to them. Just because they got rid of their TV. Well, duh, it's not like the TV kept you in the house like a captive. Somebody just didn't have the will power to turn it off and do something else. Don't get me wrong, I think it's great that people can find a way to get more out of their lives. Just don't try to sell us all this load of shit that our lives won't ever be as good until we get rid of the one eyed monster. Some of us understand moderation. I can have my TV and a real life, too.
Okay, so maybe I still get a little peeved over the TV postings
But seriously, it's all inane bullshit and the fact that I've just wasted 15 minutes bitching about it in an online journal to an audience that doesn't exist is probably fodder that some of those elitist book and TV people could use against me.
Anyhow, my mythical readers, if you actually exist and you have a book you think I should add to my list, the comment lines are open here. Since I'm not in any particular genre "mood" at the moment, hit me with whatever you've got.
And Jorge, everyone's favorite Mexican Elf of Quotational Doom has another tidbit to share from his collection:
"There are things that are so serious that you can only joke about them." -- Werner Karl Heisenberg