Comment Re:Perspective check (Score 1) 198
which is easily falsified in this instance by the simple fact that not everyone acts in this way.
If everyone had the same background, geneology, wealth, intelligence, etc, and still acted in different manners, you might have an argument for non-determinism. But that too is an impossible scenario, so we don't really know, do we? Simple birth order has been shown to change behavior between siblings. The brownian motion of society will cause us to have different histories, and thus to be determined differently.
Those of us who do believe in determinism don't automatically rule out the phenomenon of apparent free will. We simply think it's likely a perception, rather than any true capriciousness of man's mind. If you argue this, it's because your history and makeup force you to do so. If you don't, it's because they allow you not to.
It's really hard to -prove- that free will exists. I spent 2 years in philosophy classes listening to people try. It's no more settled than whether some guy 2000 years ago really died for our sins. It's also usually argued with the same level of non-fact based vehemence, too.