You're changing the subject. Putting aside the requirements for suits (have you seen what top-earning developers get in Silicon Valley? And what they wear to interviews), the point is that you can get a suit in a number of different places, but if AT&T is the only internet provider you have access to, you sort of have to agree to their terms. If Men's Warehouse decided that they wanted to require forced arbitration, I could go to Jos A Banks, or get something online, or go to Nordstroms, or Target, or whatever. We're not (in this thread) talking about whether or not internet access should be free -- only that it's required, and that means that if there's only one place you can get it from, that is a very limited definition of "freedom"