Comment Re:if you think it's over... (Score 1) 685
>Now, it's worth noting first of all that most small-scale
>copyright infringements are not criminal offences.
What do you base that one? Even copying just a single file can actually a criminal act. There are other exceptions though. For example copying computer software for private use is not a criminal offence.
>If TPB's goal was to help people share maybe ten or twenty
>copies of a file, then it may be they were not intending to
>help a criminal offence, despite the fact that they were
>intending to help a copyright violation.
If we disregard the fact that even for a single file it would be a possible criminal offense one can't look at the general goals of "The Pirate Bay" that is not of interest. There must be an intent by each person at trial for each specific act of copyright infringment part of the trial (I think there are some 20-30 works specified). Of course, one must also show that they also helped or took part actively for each case.