It's an argument for not going anywhere as human explorers where you could inadvertently start off life on a new planet that doesn't have it yet.
Telepresence is okay, same technology used e.g. for exploring the deeps of the sea too deep for human explorers to visit, or nuclear reactors etc, and this technology will surely continue to develop so that it is almost the same as going there yourself - though you would need to be in orbit around Mars to do it because of the lightspeed time lag from Earth to Mars.
You can't rule out an argument just because you don't like the conclusions, if the reasons for it are cogent. I believe the potential dangers are real, hard to quantify but a risk that one shouldn't responsibly take without much more knowledge than we have now.
Conditions on Mars are similar to those in cold Anatartic deserts on Earth where life survives, similar enough so that there is a possibility life may get a foothold there. Then once it does, life has a way of modifying its environment to make it possible to spread.
In that way just a few organisms from earth, from e.g. the faeces of a human explorer or just hijacking a ride on skin cells that flake off the skin could establish a foothold on Mars, then after the first human explorers leave, the most hardy of them could multiply and spread, carried by the wind they could spread widely and fast. Next time you return to Mars, the planet could be covered in patches of organisms derived from skin bacteria or organisms that live on human faeces, but evolved - would evolve rapidly since there are so many generations, similar to the way disease organisms evolve in hospitals.
Mars is cold now but scientists who study it think that it may be possible to make it much warmer by starting some process that gradually releases the CO2 and water vapour into the atmosphere. Life might well do that. After as short a time as a few centuries, it could become as warm as Earth nearly, with dense atmosphere especially at the bottom of volcano craters and water on the surface and running streams. The gas however can only be kept for a few hundred thousand years, then escapes and after that the planet is so dry and with little CO2 left that from then on, the planet is then an inhabitable desert (bar heroic intervention with colliding comets etc).
It would be possible to terraform responsibly, decide what you want to seed the planet with first, choose organisms that you know work well and that will spread, and create good conditions for further development. But I don't think we know enough to do that yet. Also I think the planet may be needed in the future, for the reasons I gave. Do we really want it to be an uninhabitable desert for billions of years into the future after a brief flourishing of a few hundred thousand years of life?
Can still do robotic exploration and explore Mars by telepresence. And there are plenty of places in the solar system that aren't suitable for life such as the asteroids, moon, mercury etc.
In our solar system it only rules out Mars, Europa, Titan just possibly (not the surface can't imagine Earth life would live there but maybe below the surface) and some of the minor moons with active venting - and just possibly the atmosphere of Jupiter too which is fairly warm at some levels.
A remote possibility also for the higher atmosphere of Venus, maybe earth life could survive there.
At least according to current knowledge, the rest of the solar system is likely to be fine for human exploration. Conditions are so harsh that any life we seed will be limited to our habitats (unless life evolves to be able to spread in a vacuum).
Yes I agree, it is probably only single cell organisms if there is life there, since life on Earth took a long time to progress beyond single cells, and probably only single cell organisms could be transported by meteorite to Mars.
But a single cell is a very complex thing, here on Earth anyway so it could be easily have very complex single cell organisms, and unique to Mars almost certainly if they have evolved for the conditions there - and maybe a completely different line of evolution from anything we have on Earth. And it could be wiped out before we even know it exists, we might never know what happened even.
Depends on the organism. Viruses are simple, but some single cell organisms are like huge cities with different components interacting in complex ways, a complex structure that has evolved over billions of years. If life has evolved on Mars, it is possible that it may have got as far as complex single cell organisms.
.