Comment Re:Liar. (Score 1) 431
Regarding tones, I recently read that they came about with the loss of final consonants. When a word ended in a voiced consonant, the consonant was dropped and the word took on a lower tone. Similarly, voiceless consonants became higher tones. Now Mandarin only has (I think) the
I also read a paper by Olle Kjellin which discussed tones in Tibetan, which, he argues, is at a different (earlier) stage of this transition. Tibetan has both final consonants and tone, and the tone is entirely predictable only using phonological rules given the words (with their consonants, which are not always pronounced). Interesting read.