Comment Re:They are a gimmick (Score 1) 445
They are a gimmick. If you want to use post-it notes for a burn chart or a RTM, go for it. What does forcing everyone to go stand there for 15 minutes a day accomplish? As he mentioned when stuff happens it's always dealt then and there by interaction between team members. No one waits for the next day's stand up, nor should they. If someone needs help or has a question they do it in real time, not at the stand up.
If he gets hit by a bus as a team lead they'll have to replace him, and any one of half a dozen main techniques for tracking the design and development of requirements suffice for the hand off as good or better then post-it notes. SCRUM/AGILE didn't invent communication between team members nor tracing requirements in a visible format. It's just a catchy name that over the course of a months long process wastes about 5% of your total project time because everyone in the meeting already knows everything that matters to them that's going to be said in the stand-up most of the time.
If he gets hit by a bus as a team lead they'll have to replace him, and any one of half a dozen main techniques for tracking the design and development of requirements suffice for the hand off as good or better then post-it notes. SCRUM/AGILE didn't invent communication between team members nor tracing requirements in a visible format. It's just a catchy name that over the course of a months long process wastes about 5% of your total project time because everyone in the meeting already knows everything that matters to them that's going to be said in the stand-up most of the time.