Comment Encryption follows the same debate as firearms (Score 2) 105
The old tautology, "if you outlaws firearms, only outlaws will have firearms" applies to Tor. (In fact, I'd go as far as to argue that many cryptographic mechanisms are covered by the second amendment, especially if you consider cryptography's military purpose, and that some ciphers have been regulated by the DOD as munitions. They cover the same role in protecting your property, identity and reputation from aggression, and as the "well regulated militia" clause demands, pseudonymous discussions are necessary tools to help people discuss political matters.)
The simple truth is you can shut down all the law-abiding people with Tor nodes, and the botnet creators will just run Tor nodes on their network. It would be absolutely trivial for botnet owners to get together and set up huge Tor networks and put access up for pay on the black market.