Comment Skills gap and immigration policy (Score 1) 630
We have a pretty terrible level of unemployment and underemployment in this country and yet, many employers claim to have difficulty finding workers.
Why??? There's such a thing as supply and demand and at a high enough price, you can find someone. Employers may not agree, but that just means that they can't wrap their head around what they actually have to pay. And of course perish the thought of hiring someone who hasn't already done the job either. There's a shift of mindset that has to occur here about the pay those who can do deserve, and the opportunities those who might be able to should be afforded.
I have really mixed feelings here because I know a lot of good people here on H1-Bs. Here's the thing, in the short term people do compete for a fixed pie, and once you're out of this business for more than 9 months it's next to impossible to re-enter... I know a lot of people who found themselves in that situation, too. So, it's hard to make the argument that H1-Bs visas increase the demand in a way that's broadly helpful to the locally resident software grunts.
Of course, that's not the whole point... we are also, with competition trying to reduce costs and create positive ripple effects that increase competitiveness and aid hiring in other industries, too. And I do understand targeting... the "give me your poor" line on lady liberty is a beautiful sentiment but not sane U.S. domestic policy so you have to be a little choosy. So why not software?
If we are trying to do targeting based on a perceived shortage, let's go back to the laws of supply and demand and figure out what they're telling us. The most objective way to measure a shortage is not based on the amount of whining, but based on prices. Most of the highest paid professions in this country are in the medical field. I'm not saying that high pay isn't deserved, I'm just saying that the eye popping character of it all should command our attention and make us think about what it's doing to say, anyone who's sick without insurance and to our deficit. Rather unlike software, we have a compelling national interest in trying to supplement this labor market.