Comment Re:What exactly don't you like about the essay? (Score 1) 458
To give you one short example, "Unfortunately, the overwhelming majority of humanities and social sciences lean left (about 95%), which creates enormous confirmation bias, changes what’s being studied, and maintains myths like social constructionism and the gender wage gap", which I think you'll agree contains the implied statement [the gender gap is a myth]. In the footnote it says that the well known numbers are a result of bad averaging, but "For the same work though, women get paid just as much as men".
However, there is widely accepted research that even compensating for variables to avoid other factors, there is still a (smaller) pay gap. Not just the "left leaning social sciences" but also the US government, and that's why Google can be sued for such a thing.
So we could leave that at "the essay has a mistake", which probably can happen to anyone writing an essay or a line of code as in your example. But what are the consequences of this specific mistake:
* It denies the existence of the very thing Google is claiming in court to be trying to address
* It denies and actual known problem that affects ~30% of the employees of Google. That denial is alienating to that people affected by the problem (as a short sighted person I would feel alienating to hear someone saying "medical insurance shouldn't cover prescription glasses, short sightedness is a myth").
* Getting public, it alienates also a huge segment of the public (including potential hires)
So, he made a wrong statement, that fuels legal problems to his employer, causes bad PR, and alienates a large percentage of his coworkers making it harder to put it on a team. It would have been surprising if they didn't fire him.
There are actually many other incorrect reasonings in the essay (including taking known correlations which are true data, and giving them causality and meaning that are not known science, and using those to justify applying practices that promote equality.