Comment Re:Dolphin stranding in ancient Greece (Score 1) 323
> Fag. Better?
Thank you for restauring cosmic equilibrium. This is now an average Slashdot discussion.
And you are absolutely right, I am a history buff.
You are also right about multiple causation and the fact that a known cause A for a given observation doesn't preclude the existence of an unknown cause B.
Here, scientific prudence recommends that we correlate an observation with historical occurrences before we attribute it to a new factor. If there was any obvious inner ear damage in stranded mammals, the obvious cause would be sonar. To the best of my knowledge, no such damage was found in stranded mammals. This seems to go against the man-made sound explanation.
On the other hand, some dolphin autopsies showed evidence of bacterial infection of nervous tissue. Now that is an interesting finding. I also read an interesting hypothesis about cerebral amoeba infection. I'd like to see these plausible causes eliminated before going after a less-than-obvious possible cause. Occam's razor and all that.