If I am downtown and need to travel 1-3 miles I have a few options:
1. Walk (ok if weather and time permit, often this is not great for those two reasons)
2. Subway - depending on where I am going this either costs about half of an Uber and/or takes 3 times as long
3. Bikeshare - cost is a bit high, I end up arriving sweaty and the ride is often not too safe or is on the slower side
4. Electric Scooter - almost the same cost as Uber, probably a bit slower in most cases, not as safe
5. Drive - parking is easily double or triple the cost of Uber not to mention the lost time looking for a space
6. Taxi - hard to get one and cost about double of an Uber
7. Bus - takes about 4-5 times longer to arrive due to bus routes being terrible in almost all cases
One of these options has door to door option, reasonable cost, climate control, relative safety, and almost no effort to pay attention during transit.
Until the market presents a better option it is going to be Uber/Lyft for these city rides for me...