Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment You're assuming they'll return the ore to earth (Score 2) 531

Both you and the article authors are making the assumption that they want to return the ore to earth, which is ridiculous as there's already plenty of iron ore on earth. The fact that one of the team members is NASA's Mars mission planner should be a clue. Mining an asteroid with robots and sending the ore to Mars is the cheapest way to get concentrated iron ore in one spot on Mars. It's more efficient than sending it from earth or mining it on Mars.

This iron could then be used for the construction of a large Mars base. These guys are planning a lot further ahead that you give them credit for.

Comment Re:Gave up on Wikipedia long ago (Score 1) 225

Say you are thinking about editing Wikipedia. Now you come to this thread (or any other recent thread about Wikipedia). Do you still want to edit?

Yes. This wouldn't change my opinion of Wikipedia, rather this would make me think that a lot of slashdot posters have an over-inflated view of their own writing abilities.

Except for me, of course. [citation needed]

Comment Re:Gave up on Wikipedia long ago (Score 1) 225

I feel like going through all the slashdot comments like this that basically say "I made a great edit and it was reverted for no reason" and adding [citation needed] to them, because not a single one of you has provided a link to your allegedly great edit. Maybe you're just not as good an author as you think you are? Please prove me wrong with a link.

Comment Re:What's the temperature Kenneth? (Score 1) 141

You can take anything to extremes and make it silly.

Indeed - but a reductio ad absurdam is most effective when the initial premise (in this case that more heat is good) is false. I'm not disputing that life could exist on Venus though since it also has usable temperature gradients, as evidenced by its weather. However we're better off looking for life on a planet or moon that doesn't destroy spacecraft within an hour of their landing on the surface, which Venus does.

Comment Re:What's the temperature Kenneth? (Score 5, Insightful) 141

I assume then that the interior of the sun would be a good place to look for life, because of all the heat?

You don't need a high temperature to drive the chemistry of life - you need a temperature gradient so that work can be done by transferring heat energy from one location to another. Titan has this due to internal heating from tidal forces, as has Europa. Life may operate at a slower pace in a cold environment, but the right catalysts could improve this.

Slashdot Top Deals

There are two ways to write error-free programs; only the third one works.

Working...