Comment The problem with income tax in the real world. (Score 1) 866
I don't have that big a problem with taxing people over $200K. What worries me is that enacting any tax makes it a lot easier to add more.
I lived in Tennessee once, where the state constitution says no income tax, period. The government howled constantly about how badly they needed one, but no constitutional amendment seemed to get passed (and reelection was a problem for proponents.) The Attorney General stated publicly that he thought he could beat the constitution in court, but the governor declined to let him try. No one believed that a "nominal" one or two percent tax would stay nominal, once our constitutional protection was gone.
At the time the justification was "saving" TennCare (state run insurance that had just gone broke; I made too much to use it, not enough to buy my own anywhere.) I would have been highly annoyed to work and pay taxes to provide free insurance to others, while my family stayed one major illness from bankruptcy (maybe we could have gotten TennCare then.)
Another difficulty for the TN Taxers was North Carolina next door: very high taxes (for the southeast, anyway ; ) ), more and higher fees on just about everything (slightly lower sales tax, though), no TennCare, and just as big a budget crisis.