The problem with hi-tech solutions in schools is how they are used.
First, this is coming from a tech guy. I have a technical degree and have have been using Linux since '96. You can't call me a Luddite, but I have to question whether introducing tech for techs sake instead of concentrating on the three R's is what kids need, and if it is, are our schools the place to teach tech?
Is the objective to TEACH or to be cool? I have been observing what my kids do in school. They attend schools that can afford whatever tech solutions they want, but is "the best" what we want? Is it a crutch? Does it just help lazy teachers?
Does technology replace teaching? When a student has bad handwriting, the teacher can request a free laptop for that student's use. The student never improves his handwriting and the teacher can read the student's work.
I see students in middle school and high school authoring a power point presentation each week, and maybe three essays each semester. Will they ever learn to write essays or reports, or are these dead arts?
They wanted me to sign a permission slip to make it my responsibility for the safety of a video Ipod (about three years ago) that my son would bring home so he could watch classroom instruction that the teacher did not want to bother to show them during school time. My son lost the $5 pedometer he we had responsibility for the year before. Should I entrust him with a $400+ (at the time) video Ipod? Since I did not give him permission to bring home the Ipod, he had to stay after school to watch the material.
Why can't these teachers show the material during class time? They tell me that there are copyright issues with putting it on the Internet, and I guess they have never heard of password access. They tell me that the Ipod solution will only work with the expensive Ipod, not with software we can install on our home home computer (some kids may not have home computers) or the $29.95 mp3 player my kids have.
The school decided to teach "blogging". Why you need to teach middle school kids to blog is beyond me. They assigned them usernames consisting of their first name, last initial, and the period they were in a specific classroom. This information was available to anyone on the Internet. I informed them that knowing that username Joannahr203-7, was Joannah R and she was in room 203 during 7th period could be a security risk for poor Joannah! The principal told me he was sure that the blogs were not available to anyone outside the school (they were) and that IT people would make sure it was safe for the children (it isn't). My son realized this was a security risk on his own and ignored the teacher and chose a safe pseudonym.
Perhaps safe "HEX" is best taught at home.