Exactly. The problem with laptops in class or lab classrooms is that it is either impossible (CS Lab/writing lab/ compiter classroom) to put the computers aside or very difficult (laptops). You can't use the best tool for the job if it takes 20 minutes to switch tooling. You end up picking the least bad tool and using it forever.
My ideal classroom is one in which there are computers that are small enough to be out of the way, under the desk, built in to the desk or some such. The screen is a micro laser projector and a pull up/down screen (slightly translucent for classroom management purposes). The keyboard is either a laser projected keyboard or has an easy place to hang when not in use, and the mouse is the same. Time from "Hey lets do a quick computer lab" to "Now open VirtualChemLab and load lab 12" should be something like 30 seconds. Try doing that with a set of laptops. When the lab is done and we are ready to discuss the results and do some practice problems, it should take the same amount of time to have a clear desk. Students log in as they enter the classroom then can put the computers away but stay logged in all period long. (Even better log in as they get to school and stay logged in all day switching automatically as they move to different classrooms.)
The internet connection should be nearly always off. Not blocked, since we all know that doesn't really deter the smart students, but actually not connected. No evading filters and blocks, no games, no cat and mouse, just have the internet connection on when it is needed/wanted and off otherwise. It should be like the computers, there when useful, and not distracting when not in use (A tool).
Would any of this help a poor teacher teach better? Probably not. But it would enable good and great teachers to innovate without having the tech get in the way. In a chemistry classroom the standard 8 or 10 wet labs could be supplemented with many more mini virtual labs that fit seamlessly into the lecture (30 seconds remember :). In a physics classroom similar things can go on. But if you displace all the workspace with computers then you lose the ability to do real labs with hands and eyes. In a computer programming classroom, teachers might actually put the computers away every once in a while and teach fundamentals. In an english classroom, teachers wouldn't have to schedule time in the "computer lab", take the kids to the lab, get them logged in, help those who forgot their passwords because they only get into the lab every few months. etc. etc. etc.
Oh, and a cell phone jammer :)
And I call bull crap on all the posts that argue "all we need to know these days is how to google".
Same to all those who say students need pervasive internet access. How many real world adults can shut out the thousands of distractions on the internet during work hours and work productively for a full day? Now how can you expect teen age infants to outperform you in a classroom without the financial incentive that enables you to "work productively" day in and day out.