Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Atheists Unite... as a religion (Score 1) 845

I am not arguing either way regards original proposition of Atheism=Religion, however, regarding:

In atheism, just as in agnosticism, there is no canon, no dogmas, no defined set of rules...It all depends on how convinced you are that there is no God.

You could also say similar things for Christendom or Islam or any other religion.

Here is the defense of my statement: In Christendom there is really only one common belief, and that is Jesus=Savior. Look at Eastern Orthodox vs. Catholicism vs. Unitarian vs. LDS etc. Sure there is the Bible and all, but there is so much done and believed by Christendom that is nowhere found in it, and not believed or done that is in it.

As for Islam, it's pretty fractured also. Thanks to Iraq, the western world (Even a Fox News Watcher) now knows about those sects within Islam. See also Islamic Schools and Branches

Much the same for other religions.

Some may argue that Atheism doesn't effect the actions of non-believers in #god, I argue the exact same could be said for much of those who profess belief.

That all being said, I think that to some, Atheism would be their religion; others, just how they were raised; others, a way not to be constrained by a 'moral code' not of their defining others, resultant of revulsion at the idea of eternal torture; and many many other reasons. Depends on the person.

Comment Re:For once, I'm fine with being locked out... (Score 1, Insightful) 271

For a kid below the age of about 7 the world is a magical place and santa is a part of that wonder so is flying raindeer and elves.

I'm 31 and the world is still a magical place. (metaphorically) Isn't life (nature) itself magical enough? And I never said imagination would be verboten.

The world for most of us is a much more mundane place even with Christianity wedging itself into our magical festival theres not much belief in elves or flying raindeer for the Christians.

I didn't know you worshiped the sun...

It's not really christian.

Like I said before, I knew the truth about Christmas when I was little, including where it came from and how it was 'christianized.'

It's a time for being nice to each other and if magic is real isn't that fantastic isn't the world better for magic? now tell me why you want to suck that joy out of your childrens lives?

Every day of the year is a great time to be nice to each other. That's how I try my best to do it. It also sounds like you wish there was something supernatural to the universe. I see that in pretty much all humanity. I wonder why...

As for the joy in childrens lives and sucking it out; Reality is never so harsh as when you just step out of Fantasy. Many people believe knowledge destroys innocence. Knowledge in fact preserves innocence. Innocence will keep you joyful.

now you can be cynical and see it all as a waste of money and exploitation of your wallet but really the look of happiness as your kids unwrap their presents, well worth it.

Actually Science and the Bible agree that money doesn't buy happiness. And where did you see me say that giving (including gifts) was wrong or bad. 364 other days to do that w/o having to lie. If I have kids, I indeed do plan on giving gifts, year round, to them. Why not try an unexpected time and unexpected gift if you want to see joy on someone's eyes.

I ask you to notice today what actually makes those around you happy. The actual items given, the association of friends and family, the action of gift-giving and gift-receiving, or Santa Claus and flying reindeer.

There is plenty of time for the drudgery that most of us live with the worlds better with santa, and a little magic

I feel for your drudgery. I really do. Maybe the drudgery is partly because all non-essential consumption largely revolves around one day of the year?* Is this world too far gone for a person to be unable to find joy in reality? Again, it's almost as if Humans needed magic or the supernatural for happiness or joy.

*Black Friday, closely connected with Christmas.

Comment Re:For once, I'm fine with being locked out... (Score 0, Troll) 271

"magic of Santa Claus" "purer hearts"

I'm sorry, maybe I've been brainwashed, but I always thought that pure hearts didn't believe in/perpetuate lies.

OTOH, the world w/o Christmas would surely put a severe crimp in the economy of said world...

P.S. Why don't you ask experienced LE when is the worst time of the year for crime/Domestic Abuse/etc. Guess what the answer will be?

Comment Re:For once, I'm fine with being locked out... (Score 1) 271

That said, it is damn fun being a parent and following santa and all that.

I am not a parent, but if I ever do have a child, I don't plan on lying to him or her. Also my parents never celebrated Christmas and I never felt left out. I knew the reality about Christmas and Santa Claus since the time I knew there was such a thing.

bah, hard core atheist. really? Why teach (or allow to be taught to) your children blatant religious lies?

Comment Re:Lie, cheat, and steal for Christ! (Score 1) 206

I don't do this often, and I did look, but [citation please]

This is what I found in Wikipedia:

"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ. The materialism of affluent Christian countries appears to contradict the claims of Jesus Christ that says it's not possible to worship both Mammon and God at the same time."

* As quoted by William Rees-Mogg in The Times [London] (4 April 2005) {not found}. Gandhi here makes reference to a statement of Jesus: “No servant can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon." (Luke 16:13); also partly quoted in Christianity in the Crosshairs : Real Life Solutions Discovered in the Line of Fire (2004) by Bill Wilson

There seems to have been something on snopes about this but I couldn't find it...seems to no longer be there.

I'm not trying to pick a fight, if its there, even in a dead tree reference, let me know where. Thank you

Comment Re:Of course, there is another solution (Score 0) 721

One response could be "You're preaching to the Choir" Please read carefully my whole post. Here's a little tidbit, research Mitochondrial Eve and Y-Chromosomal Adam and see how well they line up with Eve and Noah...

Now as to your quote from 2 Peter, don't forget John 12:28,29. "Father, glorify thy name. Then came there a voice from heaven, [saying], I have both glorified [it], and will glorify [it] again. The people therefore, that stood by, and heard [it], said that it thundered: others said, An angel spake to him."

People will believe what they want. Even the Bible gives people that option. Deuteronomy 30:19: "I call heaven and earth to record this day against you, [that] I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing: therefore choose life, that both thou and thy seed may live."

I'm not sure of your personal theology, but I think the best witness a Christian can give, along with oral testimony is 'show by example.'

Comment Re:Of course, there is another solution (Score 0) 721

As to the raising from the dead, I agree there is no proof that it happened other than the Bible. Really how could we prove anything about Alexander or Constantine or anyone else from history other than King Tut? (we have his body)

Uhhh....maybe the fact there are *more* scriptures mentioning them?

I'm not sure what you mean. Alexander the Great was not named in the Bible. Referred to here: Daniel 8:20-22 My point was that those people are in secular history *not in the bible* and we believe they existed... Why not discount them too? Maybe you were using satire?

I do remember that a card carrying scientist (I remember not who) on npr said to 'resurrect' someone, all you would need is their dna and a really good MRI... (or some kind of 'brain backup') Scientifically theoretically possible.

Oh yeah, they had plenty of that stuff 2000 years ago, that is common knowledge!

I'm not saying that is how it happened. I was saying that it was *scientifically* conceivable. I do agree that it would have to be God or an alien race that had a 3500~ year jump on us. (a thousand or so Light years to get here)

Here is something interesting though, Pretty much every "Messiah" back at that time was thoroughly excoriated by the Jews. But they mention nothing at all about Jesus. Even if he was made up, surely they would point out that fact seeing as Jesus had followers that history does talk about. See the burning of Rome 64 CE. Tacitus talks about it here: Great Fire of Rome

Maybe there was some guy called Jesus, thinking he was 'The Son Of God' and some believing that. But the NT was written about 300 years after his death. If I fall and scratch my pinky, after it has been forwarded five times I will have broken my neck and after ten times I will be in loose pieces and to be glued together again. Leave alone if something has to be forwarded for threehundred years. A guy will start with sweaty feet and end up walking on water.

Umm... Papyrus 52, 100 to 150 CE.

Some interesting facts here.

Also, you said the book was 2000 years old. Maybe for internal harmony with your arguments you want to revise that to 1700 years old?

As to the prophecies that are fulfilled, Here's just one, Matthew 7:21-23. There would be 'Christians' they would do 'funny' stuff and would be working lawlessness. I'll let you find those fulfillments. Also, not words of Jesus but in the Bible, is 2 Peter 2:1-3 Sects? Check! Hypocrisy? Check! That is pretty much why many people don't like "Christians"

Pretty easy to predict, knowing human nature.

And pretty uncommon for founders of religions too.

And I'll throw in one you might be interested in for free. History and the Bible both are clear that the first century Christians (and Christ) didn't involve themselves with politics. See John 18:36 or John 6:15

...So???

So any person who tries to force the teaching of ID/Creationism by legislation or laws forbidding Gay Marriage or Abortion are not following the example of Jesus Christ as described in the Bible. They also would avoid "mandate from the masses" (could be viewed as Democracy) I know that is not what you see from the vast majority of 'Christians', but that's why I mentioned it.

Slashdot Top Deals

Those who can, do; those who can't, write. Those who can't write work for the Bell Labs Record.

Working...