Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Nuclear != Radioactivity (Score 1) 822

You discover something that already existed but you, and perhaps others, did not know about. You invent something that did not actually exist. It can be solid like a jet engine or conceptual like an algorithm. Someone can no more invent radioactivity than a new exoplanet.

That is indeed the difference between "discover" and "invent" which most English speakers would probably agree on being the correct one. Etymologically, however, the word "invent" originates from the Latin verb invenire, which literally means "to find" or "to discover". That particular meaning, once incorporated into English, remains in certain authoritative dictionaries and thesauruses, such as the aforementioned Oxford Thesaurus of English:

invent
verb
1. originate, create, innovate, design, device, contrive, formulate, develop
2. conceive, think up, come up with, hit on, mastermind, pioneer
3. discover, find
4. coin, mint

I do think that what constitutes a language should largely be determined by common use if there are already perfectly cromulent replacements for certain words. Still, I would still be hard-pressed to call anyone wrong even if they made a crazy-sounding claim like "Christopher Columbus invented the Americas in 1492" as long as I know that they have the means to point and laugh at me for appearing oblivious to how their slightly obscure use of English is correct.

Hopefully, the "invent" => "discover" semantic implication will soon become archaic, so that I will never under any circumstances be tempted to drag discussions off topic like this again.

(It's actually a semantic logical equivalence. Did you know that the Wright brothers discovered the first powered airplane in 1903?)

Comment Re:Nuclear != Radioactivity (Score 1) 822

No. He discovered/named it. It existed long before him. He invented the scientific idea.

You are missing my point. Henri Becquerel invented radioactivity itself (not just the scientific theory of it), despite radioactive decay taking place before he or anyone else we know of knew about it. If he had somehow given rise to the existence of radioactive decay in the universe, he could also have been said to have invented radioactivity, but "invented" no longer directly conveys the semantics of "discovered" in that case.

Software

Submission + - The Pirate Bay Goes Legit (zelaron.com) 2

Zelaron writes: "Swedish tech company Global Gaming Factory X said Tuesday that it has reached an agreement to acquire controversial file sharing outfit The Pirate Bay for about $7.7 million. Global Gaming said it would introduce legitimate business models to Pirate Bay's Web site, which had become a haven for illegal file sharing. Pirate Bay's Swedish founders in April were ordered jailed for one year and fined $3.6 million."

Slashdot Top Deals

It's a naive, domestic operating system without any breeding, but I think you'll be amused by its presumption.

Working...