Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Ponzi scheme (Score 1) 357

It's decentralized. There's no controlling entity that can tell you who you can or cannot pay.

Another thing it allows you to do is change which company you use for payments, and yet still make payments to all the same people you could before. If you want to buy something from somebody that uses Paypal to take payments, then you're kinda stuck with using Paypal. With a Bitcoin-based system, you could pay them via a different company.

This is like asking "what's the point of SMTP when we have Gmail?"

I have a bank account and bill pay. The bank account comes with a Visa debit card that is accepted everywhere Visa is for payment and my bank offers bill pay services via ACH transfer. BitCoin cannot do either without additional hoops or places that could add attack vectors to my finances. You're twisting yourself in knots trying to justify something that just isn't better for payments unless you're buying illegal goods. Cash is also perfectly anonymous.

Comment Re:Ponzi scheme (Score 1) 357

Classifying something as a Ponzi scheme, usually involves outright fraud. ie someone is claiming that there is a huge pile of cash somewhere that doesn't actually exist.

What, like MtGox? I will say this. BitCoin in and of itself may not be a Ponzi scheme, but it sure is a mighty fine developers kit and sandbox for one. It has way too much in common for it to be used by much of anyone other than as a mechanism to create a Ponzi. Plus, add the fact that it is unregulated and you add a dimension for nefarious activity nonexistent in any other legal financial instrument today. The foundation of this wanna-be currency is flawed and fracturing. It just wasn't as good an idea as it appeared to be in someone's head. Try again.

Comment Re:Science, I think not (Score 1) 99

Sloppy thesis. My thesis had to pass review of my entire committee. They would not sign it until they had a chance to read it. I had to go through several edit cycels *after* I had been through a number of cycles by my primary adviser. Maybe I picked a hard committee, but an adviser or committee member who puts their name to sloppy research is damaging their credibility. At the time I thought it was torture, but now I appreciate the fact they wanted me to produce good research properly written up. Any adviser or committee who does otherwise is cheating the student out of an education.

You didn't pick a hard committee. You studied in a department that cared about the grad students they were sending into the world. The "Insightful" guy above obviously didn't.

Comment Re:To Clarify (Score 1) 166

OK, so they rely on a spin off project on it's own, and the rest of the world goes on with HTML5 which will continue to be improved and expanded. Which one will provide more use in the long run? So, OpenFL, is a way to avoid learning new technology. Hopefully it doesn't lead people down a one way street.

One way to a known dead end. So, yeah, face palm city.

Comment Re:Open Standards, Not stupid plugins. (Score 1) 166

Its not that I don't support the idea of cross-platform and cross-browser HTML5 solutions for tasks previously only accomplished through Flash but I think people often fail to understand it isn't all unicorns and rainbows as its made out to be.

Who writes code and thinks a new standard is going to have unicorns and rainbows? Wait, ok, idiots that don't write code and use WYSIWYG tools. Well, when you set an expectation bar too high or are looking up from the bottom of the pool ...

Comment Re:More than vector graphics (Score 1) 166

It replaced a product that was not web friendly in the Macromedia product line, Director. Director created ShockWave files, the code name that became the product name for the web plugin. Director was raster graphics based and Macromedia saw that this wasn't going to fly and created Flash as the vector graphics replacement for Director. The Flash plugin allowed SWF packaged files to play in a web page. We creatives had tools at the time, thanks for thinking we were left out, but we weren't. We weren't starving for a multimedia authoring tool that didn't suck as bad as AuthorWare, a.k.a. Awfulware.

Comment Re:Open Standards, Not stupid plugins. (Score 1) 166

Flash was one of the few holdouts of the Plugins era of the Netscape vs. IE Browser War. It came out because There wasn't a standard between the two for vector based graphics.

Bzzzt! Wrong. I was a BETA and ALPHA tester for Macromind/Macromedia when Flash was being developed. It was developed specifically to replace their Director product as it was doomed being a primarily raster graphics animation and multimedia authoring tool. To claim Flash started as anything but shows you weren't there. When Flash began the Internet was still really slow. I think the university had three T-1 lines at the time for the whole campus to use. Flash could create animated interactions (all the rage in the early 1990s) in really small files because they were vector graphics. Perfect for 56k modem users. Anyway, Flash was written as a vector animation package that also had a scripting engine (ActionScript) for controls. It handled audio files at first and eventually got video capabilities. As for HTML5, it's barely out of the blocks as a standard and folks are shooting it down? How about wait for it to mature, as it does have a bit to go. Heck, we just got CSS3 working cross browser within the last two years without gymnastics. Give it some time.

Comment Re:Ask the OSM community. (Score 1) 52

This is a problem that OSM (open street map) has solved. Either use their service, our even create your own clone - their software is likely to be all open source, and their mapping data certainly is.

Nice. I was going to say if everyone is collocated to use a big paper map on a wall. He did say they were "local". Sounds like he's trying to use tech he doesn't really need to solve a problem. But, that's most Ask /. questions these days, that and not knowing how to use a search engine to do your own research.

Comment Re:How long id a song (Score 1) 100

Why always picking on the HD manufacturers? Your GigE network runs at 1,000,000,000 bits per second, not 1,073,741,824, what a scam!

Easy. For the same reason you'd be pissed off at a builder that built the rooms ten percent or more smaller than advertised in your house, or translated requirements to meters and intentionally then built in feet. It's fraud! If you needed a twenty-by-twenty room to fit your living room in and the builder made it sixteen-by-sixteen wouldn't you be pissed? Networking technology is known to have degraded efficiency percentages due to transients, bad cables, etc. there is an acceptable amount of loss expected, but if gige only gave you 200Mbps you'd get pissed. Memory is known to have certain defects, but we usually don't tolerate those as swapping out ram is not detrimental to your stored data. When HD manufacturers went to tens to calculate HD sizes, we the consumers were defrauded. The whole change was a way to make drives that wouldn't normally pass yield sellable so the manufacturer could make more money at our expense. And we just let them...

Comment Re:changed my view of it for the better (Score 1) 192

No. The older crowd has seen its share of Ponzi schemes and economic bubbles and is simply less naive.

I will second that. The other inevitable thing about Bitcoins is that they will end up regulated and they will not remain anonymous. That's what will happen if Bitcoin is going to be successful at all as a global currency. Only idiots trust their money to anonymous, uninsured and unregulated financial instruments. The only people that make money with those instruments are the greedy and the corrupt. And before anyone says anything about businesses legitimizing them by taking payments, why wouldn't a business take your money in any form to convert to their local currency? After all, a fool and their money are easily parted.

Comment Re: US dollar (Score 1) 192

Actually, diamonds are valuable because a corrupt, immoral industry has been running propaganda campaigns to convince us of their value for generations.

That could be said of any commodity, gold, silver, oranges, etc. Society drives the value of commodities via supply and demand. If you can create demand for a limited supply of something, you're going to be rich and most likely turn corrupt.

Slashdot Top Deals

I'd rather just believe that it's done by little elves running around.

Working...