Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Your Nobel Prize Awaits! (Score 1) 754

Thanks for the reply.

If it worked doctors would be thrilled but there is no substantial evidence that it works or that it should work.

From what I understand, most of the studies done made the error of using far too small of doses. Most of the authors I've read recommend, for example, several grams of Vitamin C per day (RDA is only 65mg). And for seriously ill patients, some doctors have prescribed up to a 100 g or so intravenously.

Most doctors are not employed by hospitals and in fact in some states like California they are prohibited by law from being employed by a hospital.

Well I can't speak to the laws in the other states but I think it's safe to assume that most states do not have such a law, and in such cases it is the admins that influence heavily the treatment that is given. Even if they are not directly employed, doctors are influenced in indirect ways. Certainly you have heard of people getting unnecessary surgeries (google it for plenty of examples). Drugs are in many ways no different. Those with the gold, make the rules.

That said drug companies produce products that are proven to work.

Most drugs have ridiculous or even deadly side effects. Strain your ears to listen to the fine print/fast talk of a drug commercial next time. This is a primary benefit of vitamins over drugs: very low toxicity, and in most cases no side effects.

Walk into a GNC sometime and tell me you think there is no money there.

Not anything close to what big pharm brings in. Plus I would guess that GNC makes most of its money on creatine and related products.

Furthermore as dietary supplements" [wikipedia.org] they are largely unregulated with poor quality assurance and no requirement to demonstrate efficacy.

Here is one point where I couldn't agree more. It is not reassuring to read "These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA." Hopefully as more studies are done and the ideas become accepted by more people, this will change.

No I don't think I will.

Well I don't blame you, but it never hurts to read alternative points of view. In fact, after seeing what it has done for my friend, I would be willing to buy you a book just to check it out if you wanted.

Comment Re:Your Nobel Prize Awaits! (Score 1) 754

You bring up an important point. Most doctors and hospitals have no idea about this, and if it were legitimate and as successful as people claim, they would, right? Well possibly, except for the fact that the medical system is controlled by doctors who are controlled by drug companies and hospitals. Drugs and surgery bring in big bucks. Un-patentable vitamin supplements do not. Pick up a copy of Fire Your Doctor or Orthomolecular Medicine for Everyone for a multitude of interesting studies on the subject. (Disclaimer: I have no affiliation with the above authors)

Comment Re:Well Then (Score 1) 754

While my statement was bold, it was incorrect. I should have replaced "naturopathic medicine" with "orthomolecular medicine." Then it would be correct. As I said in response to the AC, there are many voodoo-esque forms of natural and homeopathic medicine that parade around as scientific medicine.

Comment Lets get things straight (Score 1) 754

While the documentary you linked me to is entertaining (having watched only part 1), it is imperative that I distinguish the practices that I was referring to from other types of homeopathic and naturopathic medicine, some of which are very unscientific. What I am talking about is called orthomolecular medicine, which essentially says that almost all non-genetic diseases are caused entirely by nutritional deficiencies. Note that, obviously, germs are the cause of infectious disease, but these nutritional deficiencies are what allow us to fall prey to them. These deficiencies and thus diseases can be cured by proper diet and vitamin/mineral supplements.

Comment Re:Well Then (Score 2, Funny) 754

Actually, naturopathic medicine is not only legitimate, it is superior to and will eventually replace allopathic medicine (mainstream, drug-and-surgery medicine), assuming the Singularity does not occur first. For proof, read a book or two by Linus Pauling.

As for chiropractics, I am not sufficiently informed to make a judgment.

Comment Re:That Analogy Falls Apart (Score 1) 917

Aside from meat, hemp is the only complete protein.

This is blatantly false. Alfalfa sprouts are just one example of a complete protein. Please do your research in the future.

In fact, not only is the GP correct, but meat contains no fiber, a minimum 10% fat, various drugs and hormones, and the only way to get it is to kill innocent animals! That's why I'm going vegetarian!

Comment Re:School doesn't work like you think. (Score 1) 443

And I'm saying (as others agree) it doesn't make sense to put it off. Reasons to run it well ahead of time include: to confirm the software works; to know its approximate runtime; and to have even a complete but possibly inaccurate schedule, which is infinitely better than no schedule at all.

Slashdot Top Deals

Pascal is not a high-level language. -- Steven Feiner

Working...