If you want to call it "muddy waters" you can, but most people would call it disagreeing with your claims. If *you* were interested in actually discussing the case, I would think you'd respond to the refutations, but instead you've gotten bitchy. Are you that sensitive to people disagreeing with you?
Manning didn't read all the cables himself. He saw the apache video, and in his REMF viewpoint, finally learned that war was ugly. Have you watched the unedited video in its entirety? The army investigated and saw nothing wrong, but hey, 22 year-old, demoted PFCs know better than the Army.
He then downloaded mass amounts of cables, unread, to leak (after supposedly bragging about his access level to Lamos). So what crime was he ignoring there? What illegal order was he defying?
Damn, at the end I thought you were being hilariously sarcastic, but you sounded earnest and I half expected you to start citing war movies and books, as well as every relation in the last 100 years. I'm appreciative of your family and those who have served, and I make no judgement on the fact that you haven't. But hearing stories is a little different than living them.
Not to mention, REMFs and fixed wing pilots don't exactly have the same military experience as gunships and ground troops.