Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Take the money. (Score 1) 412

Time and health are finite commodities and you never know when they'll be taken off you.

Sure, but if the fisherman could afford health care, he would be far less likely to die if he accidentally hooked himself and got an infected wound. If he had cash reserves, he wouldn't need to worry too much if he broke his arm and couldn't cast for a month or two, or if his boat were destroyed in a hurricane. If he were well off, he wouldn't have to worry too much if the fisheries collapsed due to his or his neighbors' unsustainable practices or the pollution from nearby farms and factories. If he died of skin cancer from sitting in the sun all day, his wife wouldn't have to go and work the dockyards to keep herself and the children from starving to death.

For most of history, personal wealth was not just a way to attain power for its own sake, but a way to manage risk in an uncertain, dangerous world. Recently, some of the more affluent nations have implemented safety nets that make this less necessary, but it is quite naive to think that an idyllic life of poverty generally works out well.

Comment Re:Let's forget the environment for a momnet... (Score 1) 633

It has been estimated that the amount of resources it would take to reduce CO2 emissions significantly over 100 years, is enough to completely solve the world hunger problem, in the same amount of time, even taking into account predicted population growth.

I'd be interested in seeing your proposed strategy for completely solving the world hunger problem, together with a rigorous demonstration of cost-optimality within reasonable error bounds. It has been estimated that the likelihood that you (or your favorite mouthpiece like Lomborg) made up a bunch of numbers to fit a pre-specified agenda is very close to 100%.

Comment Re:Been tried, major fail (Score 2, Interesting) 432

The referenced article mentions the project name and claimed that it was a technical success. They didn't bother to mention several technical failures, including unexpected releases of radioactive dust (some of which drifted into Canada, in contravention of a treaty), and a general inability to predict the outcome of their explosions. One of their experiments attempted to create a hill, but ended up with a crater. Another experiment did the opposite. They tried to connect two natural gas cavities, and not only failed to do so, but made the gas too radioactive for safe use. This is only a success in some weak sense, where we can move the goalposts to some relatively trivial problem, like that of making explosions underground. See also: this article.

Teller's vision of reshaping the crust to our will has a strong appeal, especially since conventional earth-moving is still expensive 50 years later. Geological structures still strongly affect the development of cities and the economy of nations, and the idea that many of the problems that arise from this can be made to disappear makes this project very compelling to those who don't consider the unexpected costs. Before we can do this well, I think our technology needs to progress to the point where we can not only produce large amounts of energy such as that produced by a fusion bomb, but also direct it in a controlled way, and we still seem to be relatively far from that goal.

Comment Re:Non-sequitur (Score 1) 357

The strikes against Oppenheimer were relatively minor (seriously, age??), and Gladwell, as usual, neglected to mention contravening evidence, presumably in an attempt to reinforce the chosen narrative. Oppenheimer's contributions to quantum mechanics and nuclear physics even at that time were absolutely huge - he wasn't some average theoretical physicist. He was well-known to have unusually keen perspective on problem-solving, and was quick to grasp the import aspects of new ideas. It seems kind of incongruous to point to some lack of administrative experience but downplay his people skills as just a tool he uses to glad-hand the power structure into giving him a job. The people skills he had were exactly what they wanted.

Comment Re:Who is dumb enough to believe a politician? (Score 1) 546

Only a fool would argue with the basic logic of the Laffer Curve. The only puny argument would be that we are on the good side of it, but history rebuts that so completely even The One didn't attempt it.

I guess I'm that fool - how sad. The main problem with the Laffer curve is a type mismatch. The space of possible tax policies is a high-dimensional system, and expected tax revenues over time depends not only on these policies, but also on additional inputs like trade policy, currency management, and vagaries of the business cycle. When Laffer attempts to distill a complex system to a single curve like this, he communicates essentially zero useful information. However, one can take something resembling a partial derivative, and ask whether cutting income tax by, e.g., 10 percent, while holding most other variables steady is expected to yield revenue growth. Fortunately, the Congressional Budget Office studied exactly that (pdf warning) in 2003, and found that you're wrong. Also, the US treasury studied historical effects (another pdf, sorry) of tax cuts and raises, and found that contrary to your assertions, the Reagan and Bush tax cuts were highly revenue-negative. The revenue act of 1964 was signed by Johnson, not Kennedy, and was also revenue-negative.

Where are your sources? Do you have any data to back up your claims?

Comment Re:Probably never about terrorists (Score 1) 717

I am 100% certain that the NSA has run this program past their lawyers and 99.9% certain that it has received congressional approval.

This sounds like a load of hot air. What unimpeachable information source gives you this sort of confidence? It is unrealistic unless you have personally seen the documentation signed. We already have plenty of evidence of the Bush administration's malfeasance in other departments. Why do you think the NSA is distinguished in this regard? If anything, their lack of public accountability makes them more corruptible, not less so.

Comment Re:remote learning (Score 2, Informative) 317

As a side note, when I was a freshman, many of my classmates did not find the TEAL lectures to be terribly effective in teaching the material.

This seems to be the big paradox of TEAL. From what I've heard among the faculty, it seems to be quite unpopular among students, but by every metric of student progress available, they actually learn substantially more than in traditional lecture classes. My own experience as an undergrad at Caltech suggests that many of the lecture classes were delivered in a way that most benefited the top 5-10 percent of the class, and a large fraction of the students were just trying to survive through the term. I think the interactivity of TEAL is good for letting the teacher know what parts are worth repeating for most people, although one might reasonably argue that the top 5-10 percent of the class is then not getting as much information as they could potentially receive. Other commenters have remarked that under a lecture regime a student could in theory do the in-class exercises at home, but this requires nontrivial initiative, and the interactive classroom more or less removes this variable.

Comment Re:No physics background here (Score 1) 265

Let me give you my take on mass. Mass is: - a point from which gravitational forces are exerted

This does not agree with the definitions of modern physics. Mass is an inertial property, i.e., resistance to acceleration under action of a force.

Light doesn't exert gravitational force on anything. It has no coordinates from which one would calculate the exertion of gravitational forces on other objects. Ergo, light has no mass.

This isn't true. Light does exert gravitational force on nearby things, because it contributes to the stress-energy tensor in general relativity. However, that force is very small, so you don't feel it in everyday situations. In the standard model of particle physics, light has no mass because the photon doesn't interact with the Higgs field.

Education

Submission + - The Dangerous Wealth of the Ivy League 1

theodp writes: "BusinessWeek reports that higher education is increasingly a tale of two worlds, with elite schools getting richer and buying up all the talent. Thanks to endowments like the one that netted Harvard $5.7B in investment gains just last year, the Ivy Plus colleges — which account for less than 1% of students — have been able to lift their spending into the stratosphere, including extravagances like $272,000-a-bed-dorms and even a $4M student-horse-housing rehab. 'People used to look at every penny,' says a Yale Dean. 'The mind-set is different now.' Meanwhile, reports BW, public colleges and universities struggle to educate 75% of the country's students in an era when most states are devoting a dwindling share of their budgets to higher ed."
Security

Submission + - Penn student at center of worldwide hacking invest (philly.com)

An anonymous reader writes: When a suspicious computer server crash at the University of Pennsylvania last year denied service to 4,000 students, faculty and staff, technicians called the FBI — triggering a case that would take agents around the world and lead to the arrest of a brilliant but brash Penn junior. Ryan Goldstein, a 20-year-old bioengineering major, conspired with a New Zealand hacker known as AKILL to use Penn's computer system as a staging ground for a 50,000-computer attack against several online chat networks, authorities said. The FBI and Secret Service are expected to announce indictments today against Goldstein, a Florida man, and three others. Police recently executed related raids in New Zealand, Florida, California and Pennsylvania. The latest came Tuesday near Philadelphia. An FBI agent from the region is in New Zealand this week, and more arrests are possible. "We've been executing search warrants all over the world in this case," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Levy. View article for more.
Space

Submission + - Space pioneers wanted

axehind writes: The ESA is preparing for future human exploration missions to Mars. They are currently looking for 12 volunteers to take part in a 520-day simulated Mars mission. The simulations will take place here on Earth inside a special facility in Moscow. A precursor 105-day study is scheduled to start by mid-2008, possibly followed by another 105-day study, before the full 520-day study begins in late 2008 or early 2009. Do you think you got what it takes?
Supercomputing

Submission + - "Mission Completed" says Grid.Org

JAMDoc writes:
On Friday, April 27, 2007, Grid.org announced it has completed its mission to demonstrate the viability and benefits of large-scale Internet-based grid computing, and will be retiring its famous efforts to support critical health research.
Grid.org was the largest and most ambitious public interest grid venture ever attempted, and thanks to Grid.org and its millions of members, dozens of similar global grid projects have been able to catch on and succeed by following its footsteps.
Here ends Grid.Org's revolutionary grid-processing effort. Having utilized the computing power of 3.7 million systems world-wide, Grid.Org chugged the equivalent of more than 500,000 years of data processing. Grid.Org's projects included drug screens for cancer, anthrax, and smallpox as well as a major contribution to the human proteome folding project.
Announcements

Submission + - Japan to Launch Magnetic Trains in 2025

SpeedyTrain writes: Magnetic trains zooming at a landscape-blurring 310 miles an hour will connect Tokyo and Nagoya by 2025, one of Japan's biggest railway operators said Friday. The new magnetically levitated, or "maglev," trains would slash the 100-minute travel time down the country's busiest transportation corridor and are envisioned as a successor for Japan's iconic bullet trains, or shinkansen, first introduced to the world in 1964.
Censorship

Submission + - Judge Dismisses Don't Date Him Girl Lawsuit

Joe Tracy writes: "The lawsuit filed by Todd Hollis against the Website Don't Date Him Girl has been dismissed on a technicality. The judge determined that the lawsuit was filed in the wrong state. The defamation of character lawsuit received a lot of publicity on TV shows like Dr. Phil and the Today show. Don't Date Him Girl allows women to "anonymously" post information on people they've dated and include a picture, name, and other personal identifying information of that person. You can read about the dismissal of the suit at http://onlinedating.typepad.com/industry/2007/04/d ont_date_him_g.html"

Slashdot Top Deals

Work expands to fill the time available. -- Cyril Northcote Parkinson, "The Economist", 1955

Working...