Comment Re:off key (Score 1) 576
It is a cycle really.
It started with the minstrel show (chances are Daniel Decatur Emmett didn't write Dixie, but he got to be the first "sell face" in American pop music), but Tin Pan Alley turned it an industry and they were in it 100% for the copyright.
Every time the music industry takes good music and turns it into cynical, cookie cutter, garbage, some listener-turned-musician turns it into something else. Then the cycle starts over again. So maybe we shouldn't think of it as cookie cutter garbage, perhaps it is just fertilizer.