I picked up the Kindle DX on release day (much to my amazement, as I figured the initial stock would go entirely to preorders) and then took it on a 2 week trip. I'm quite pleased with it, although I definitely believe that it will only appeal to a narrow market.
Pros:
- The e-ink display really needs to be seen to understand the benefit. Over time, more and more of my reading material has become electronic, and I had not appreciated how much reading long documents on my backlit laptop LCD was leading to eye-fatigue. The result was that I tended to read on my laptop in short bursts, taking frequent breaks and losing focus. With a passive display like this, I find that I naturally read for longer intervals. Contrast is not as good as paper, but being able to read in direct light really changes your reading behavior.
- The form factor is perfect for full page document reading. A netbook or small laptop, while useful for other things, is a horrible document reader. The clamshell form factor is the wrong orientation for reading pages, and if you try to turn it to read in portrait mode, you have a keyboard sticking out the side for no reason. I tried reading with a sideways 12" laptop on the bus as a graduate student, and it was pretty annoying. Anyone suggesting a real computer as an alternative to the Kindle DX should at least begin with a tablet PC.
- As a reader, the software mostly gets out of your way. The power switch just puts the system to sleep, so you can pick up the DX and be reading where you were last in about 4 seconds. Your last location is remembered in all documents, as you would expect. More sophisticated controls would be nice, but aren't a deal-breaker.
- The built-in cellular data link is not spectacular, but gets the job done. I really enjoy being able to read something, then if I encounter an unfamiliar concept, I can just start typing a phrase and hit "wikipedia". xkcd's comment about the Kindle being our manifestation of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is very true.
- The browser is definitely limited, but very convenient when you are traveling. I don't have a fancy phone, so this is the only device I own which provides nearly universal Internet access. (Yeah, I'm late to the party.) Not having a stupid cell contract to use the web browser is a huge plus.
- Battery life and weight are good. I tend to leave the wireless radio on, but even with that extra drain, I normally have to recharge every few days. At 1 lb., it is the weight of a thin hardback. You won't read it for long periods by holding it out in front of your face (see "gorilla arms"), but it doesn't take much support to a corner or an elbow to comfortably hold it.
- Being able to read the first chapter of books free is kind of neat. I don't usually buy books for the Kindle with the store, because I consider DRM-crippled data to be disposable. It is a great way to find new books to buy in dead-tree format, though.
- PDF rendering works fine. I have encountered one image in one PDF that rendered strange, but otherwise viewing PDFs has met my expectations.
Cons:
- Some people say other readers have a better e-ink display. This is my first e-ink device, so I can't comment on that.
- If you are used to reading on an LCD, it will take you a little bit to adjust. The first thing I noticed when I got the DX is that I have very poor lighting in my apartment for reading. With a backlit display, I never noticed. However, the DX needs external light, just like paper. :)
- This is not a speedy device, nor a speedy internet connection. The browser is very slow, especially on complex websites.
- The economics of the cellular link are worrying. Since it is effectively pre-paid in the cost of the device itself, Amazon does not have a strong financial incentive to improve the built-in browser. More web use means more money they have to pay to Sprint on your behalf. You see the effects of this in other device features as well. Downloading books and magazines from the Kindle store is free, but you cannot download PDFs via the web browser because of the cost to Amazon. To put PDFs on the device, you have to transfer them over USB (as you might expect) or email them to a special address you setup on the Kindle website. However, emailing files to your Kindle costs 0.15 cents per MB because it is using the cellular network. Also note that the cost for email files is computed per file, not per email. If you send four 100 kB PDFs to your Kindle in one email, you are charged 60 cents, not 15 cents. Still, it's cheap enough that I will sometimes email PDFs to myself from work for later reading as long as they are less than 1 MB in size.
- The web browser is a little crashy on complex sites. When you encounter a problem, it will lock for a few seconds, then some kind of watchdog kicks in and the Kindle will reboot automatically. The reboot sequence takes about 30 seconds with a progress bar, and I didn't realize what was going on the first time it happened.
- The target audience for the DX is definitely someone who reads PDFs, where full-page rendering is important. If you like to read books from the Amazon store, the smaller Kindle is probably a better fit. (I've seen a lot of Kindle 2 owners bash the DX for being too big, but that's really the point.) There is less overlap between the target audience for a Kindle 2 and the Kindle DX than you might think. If you have one, you probably don't want the other.
- The keyboard is like typing on Tic-Tacs. However, if you are using the keyboard a lot, you probably want a netbook because you are either taking copious notes, or using the web in a very interactive fashion.
- Although running a Linux distribution (and possibly Java) under the hood, there is no way to load your own programs. Given the cost to Amazon for using the data link, I doubt it will ever open up, which is too bad. The Kindle DX is a decent ARM system-on-a-chip crammed into a light tablet form factor with a cellular radio and an ultra low power usage display on it. I'd bet that 3rd party developers could come up with creative uses for such a device.
In summary, the DX is a very competent PDF viewer with a good display. Amazon got the core features mostly right, and the extra features (like the web browser) are technology demos, showing where things might go in the future. Despite the price, I'm excited by the existence of a full-page reader with some marketing force behind it. Hopefully we will see more devices like this, and dropping prices as the technology is refined. After seeing the datapad props in Star Trek: TNG as a kid, I've been searching for more than a decade for something that would live up to my imagination about how those devices would work. The DX is the first thing I've used that gets the core idea right, and just needs about 300 more years of polish before it ends up on Jean-Luc's coffee table. :)