Comment Re:One Word... (Score 1) 227
Nope, Honesty is what it is all about.
Some people steal (yes, pirating is stealing and let's not quibble over the definition) what they can't have. Some people don't have the cranial capacity to understand that downloading stuff off the web is theft. The more that happens, the less money publishers and writers don't make.
Here is a side effect of pirating books. Publishers are prone to market conditions too. When the market goes south, publishers tighten up and stop taking on new writers. They also start knocking off low performing writers (low performing compared to others in the stable.) Every book that is pirated, and to the same degree where a book is swapped on an internet site, means one less sale to the author which means less money in their pocket, 6-8% of the cover price AND one less sale in their numbers column. Under performers are cut.
Pirating is NOT new, but the SCALE at which it can occur on the Internet is new. Back when vinyl was copied to cassettes, I bet the total impact was less than 1% of album sales because there really wasn't a big distribution channel, at least not in the US for illegal album copies.
But you know as well as I that with electronic copies, the barriers are completely removed.
That is why publishers want DRM. And, I think what killed the music industry and put Apple on top was NOT DRM, but the stakeholders--labels, distributors, and sellers--to come up with an *interoperable* format and method so that any song could be played on any device while still enforcing DRM.
Some people steal (yes, pirating is stealing and let's not quibble over the definition) what they can't have. Some people don't have the cranial capacity to understand that downloading stuff off the web is theft. The more that happens, the less money publishers and writers don't make.
Here is a side effect of pirating books. Publishers are prone to market conditions too. When the market goes south, publishers tighten up and stop taking on new writers. They also start knocking off low performing writers (low performing compared to others in the stable.) Every book that is pirated, and to the same degree where a book is swapped on an internet site, means one less sale to the author which means less money in their pocket, 6-8% of the cover price AND one less sale in their numbers column. Under performers are cut.
Pirating is NOT new, but the SCALE at which it can occur on the Internet is new. Back when vinyl was copied to cassettes, I bet the total impact was less than 1% of album sales because there really wasn't a big distribution channel, at least not in the US for illegal album copies.
But you know as well as I that with electronic copies, the barriers are completely removed.
That is why publishers want DRM. And, I think what killed the music industry and put Apple on top was NOT DRM, but the stakeholders--labels, distributors, and sellers--to come up with an *interoperable* format and method so that any song could be played on any device while still enforcing DRM.