Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:More than just a secular humanist (Score 1) 910

True enough. But making sharp observations and reaching conclusions well founded in reality was Hitchens' stock in trade. Getting Iraq right should have been a slam dunk for him.

Hitch was good at commentary on what had already happened. But no one is good at predicting the future...we are just good at congratulating ourselves after we have guessed right. I do think he could have done much better at admitting that he had been wrong.

I agree with the topic of the thread, "more than just a secular humanist", but in this particular case I think his pro-war sentiment was rooted in his feelings about religion, and for Hitchens war in the Middle East was a way to take up arms, in a literal way, against religion. (Yes, I get that Iraq was a secular regime, but the big-picture neocon agenda was long term regional war.) Again, I am not an apologist and do not excuse him. I think he was terribly wrong, and it is a huge blemish on his legacy. But I do believe that he was expressing his beliefs in good faith, not selling them out.

Comment Re:More than just a secular humanist (Score 1) 910

I, too, was dismayed by Hitchen's support for the war, and of course the results of the war were terrible. But I take issue with "careerist," which I take to mean that he put forward an opinion that he did not believe in for the sake of money. He was wrong, but you don't need to ascribe an evil motive.

Comment Re:Same broken solution to a cost problem (Score 1) 768

1. Colleges will stop having 12 directors and VPs for things like diversity who get paid $200,000 a year, stop paying $5,000,000 a year on gardens and lawns, and many other useless things because they have free money so why care?

Those people and things pay for themselves. At many schools, the endowment is as big a part of the financial picture as tuition, and the alumni who are writing checks care about things like diversity, gardens and lawns.

Comment Re:the problem... (Score 1) 1452

I am only saddened that Job's very successful methods of tax evasion and exploitation put him so far out of reach of more ethical men such as RMS.

What exactly would have happened if Stallman had gotten into reach of Jobs? I think he might have given him a handjob, but that is just my opinion based on my own telepathic conversations with Stallman regarding current events.

I didn't say that Stallman is wrong on substance. Do his style and timing matter? For a spokesman for a movement, yes.

Given the quantity of water you are carrying for RMS, you might want to be careful with the word "fanboi".

Comment the problem... (Score 1) 1452

...is not that Stallman is wrong, or that he had an opinion about it, or that he expressed his opinion about it. It is that he offered his opinion, without being asked, while the corpse was still warm. It is just not nice to tell grieving people that they are stupid, even if maybe they are, a little, about one thing. Of course, he has the freedom to express his hurtful opinion. But what should be protected is only his right to say it. He is not protected from being called a dick.

Comment selection bias (Score 1) 380

Visitors arrived either through organic searches or through advertisements on other sites, and Aptiquant made a note of which browser each test taker was using

Targeting people who google for IQ Test seems like a great recipe for cherry-picking self-important douchebags. It's no wonder that they use niche browsers.

Slashdot Top Deals

Congratulations! You are the one-millionth user to log into our system. If there's anything special we can do for you, anything at all, don't hesitate to ask!

Working...