Comment Re:1.5 Trillion?! (Score 1) 510
I bet the numbers are getting multiplied artificially. I have no proof this is how they got the number but I bet it's some broken algorithm like this:
User A has a song on limewire.
User B has the same song limewire.
User C downloads and shares the song and gets bits from both users.
User C is now also sharing the song and user D comes and gets fragments from each of the users.
Each user is potentially contributing to the theft of the song but you can't say there were 100,000 illegal downloads of the song and each user is responsible for 100,000 thefts creating 400,000 thefts. If user D never shared it, the number of thefts would probably still be the same unless someone got queued up and canceled their download.
If someone decided it was taking to long to steal a song then you can imagine their desire to obtain the song was probably not that great in the first place meaning they probably wouldn't have bought it.
I'm glad they are putting out such silly numbers. I bet people would feel less inclined to share at $3 a song thinking, "Wow, I don't really want to get busted and have to pay out $1800." as opposed to people saying, "Screw it! Let them sew me for $429,000 because they'll never see it."
User A has a song on limewire.
User B has the same song limewire.
User C downloads and shares the song and gets bits from both users.
User C is now also sharing the song and user D comes and gets fragments from each of the users.
Each user is potentially contributing to the theft of the song but you can't say there were 100,000 illegal downloads of the song and each user is responsible for 100,000 thefts creating 400,000 thefts. If user D never shared it, the number of thefts would probably still be the same unless someone got queued up and canceled their download.
If someone decided it was taking to long to steal a song then you can imagine their desire to obtain the song was probably not that great in the first place meaning they probably wouldn't have bought it.
I'm glad they are putting out such silly numbers. I bet people would feel less inclined to share at $3 a song thinking, "Wow, I don't really want to get busted and have to pay out $1800." as opposed to people saying, "Screw it! Let them sew me for $429,000 because they'll never see it."