Comment Re:Stop overselling (Score 3, Insightful) 213
Hi iSeal. I work for an ISP that sells consumer broadband. Being a small ISP, we resell dsl service on the incumbent telephone company's network, however the backbone connection is through another provider. Even during peak hours, the capacity of our backbone connection is not threatened. If it were, it would be our prerogative to increase our capacity in proportion to the usage requirements of our customer base. While some smaller companies may split 50mbps connections between a thousand users (though you'd probably only manage comfortably with 500 users), bandwidth becomes more cost effective to purchase in larger volumes, so if your customer base is large enough, you needn't worry as much about clogging the tubes.
Now I'm not in any way opposed to traffic shaping. Whether we admit it or not, there have been traffic shaping rules in existence in networks for years. Be it an office increasing QoS on their VoIP lines, or an ISP ensuring that HTTP gets a little bit better treatment than SSL.
The issue that has been faced lately by many smaller ISP's is the lack of transparency of the major carriers (i.e. videotron/bell etc) and their imposition of shaping rules on customers or resellers without any prior notice, and even in Bell's case, outright denying that there was any traffic shaping. At this point in time, Bell has yet to offer any evidence that their tubes are clogged. Given Bell's track record of not scaling their network as fast as their customer basis, it wouldn't surprise me if they had congestion at some points, however if this were the case, and it was not feasible to scale up their network accordingly, at the very least providing options with regards to traffic shaping would be at least somewhat of a sane thing to do. There is nothing inherently wrong with ISPs charging different rates for services with different levels of priority on their network. Why not charge $5 or $10 more per month for a non-throttled connection. In my experience, most power-users would be willing to pay for that extra kick, provided they are not being bullied by the incumbents...