Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Perhaps a study of regression (Score 3, Insightful) 729

Wars are started by people, often for a political motive.

Quite an empty argument. You can say that about all conflicts attributed to one cause or another. It's not oil, it's politics. It's not ethnic strife, it's politics. Homophobia in Uganda? Bad people, not bad religion. Vatican coverup of pedophile priests? Fallability of people, not the religion. Etc, etc.

Also, since religion and politics have essentially been the same or overlapped to a big degree, political motivations may well be the same as religious. I'd say that it's the case even today to some degree. It certainly seems that way in the US, and is obviously true for many middle eastern nations and groups.

I'd even say that the current "war on terror" is mostly a bunch of idiots who are trying to use the trappings of religion for political purposes, and it isn't the religion itself that is the motivating factor.

Obviously there are political motivations, but you don't have to look far on either side to find religious zealotry as a strong force, especially for those who do the fighting. Blaming only religion is simplistic, but so is not blaming religion at all.

Mao Zedong and Joseph Stalin, both professed atheists, can account for far more death, misery, wars, and famine than almost all religious leaders or even religiously inclined political leaders in the entire history of humanity combined.

Atheism is the lack of belief in gods. It's hard to argue that someone went to war or comitted genocide based on the lack of belief in something. No war I've ever heard of has been fought to spread a lack of belief.

The anti-religious dogma of communism isn't effectively different than the anti-religion dogma of religion towards other faiths—your beliefs bad, mine good. The lack of a supernatural god seems quite inconsequential seeing how god-like Mao and Stalin were in many respects, and how dogmatic their teachings were. North Korea is a good modern example of how this works. It's not because of atheism that North Koreans risk their lives to save a portrait of Dear Leader, it's because of the very dogmatic, unquestioning system that can make religion fuel wars and oppression.

Comment Re:Isn't that public infrastructure? (Score 1) 349

If it works like I think, I'd say it's a good thing. The Øresund Bridge between Sweden and Denmark is entirely user financed, despite being built by the respective governments. It seems fairer to let actual users pay for infrastructure like this than to take it from taxes that can be better spent on other things that can't pay for themselves so easily.

Comment Re: Now you notice?? (Score 2) 757

Good point. You might add The Big Bang Theory, CSI and Futurama to a list of shows popular with viewers and ciritics.

Before anyone points out the science in these shows isn't real science, I'd like to point out that neither was the science in Star Trek. And yet it inspired plenty of people who went on to real science in some form.

Comment Re:Ban guns (Score 1) 2166

We are talking about Europeans here (see the comment I replied to), a category in which both Germans and Polish fall. People you are culturally and geographically close to (as you yourself point out) can be described as your own.

You should carefully consider the sordid history of US wars and interventions (installing friendly tyrants to do your genocides for you), as well as the high horse you're on.

Comment Re:charges seem implausible (Score 2) 840

Sex with a sleeping person is very possible. If you can't imagine how, you're not imaginative enough. Or creepy enough, I guess. Some people are heavy sleepers. Other gets very drunk. Etc, etc.

The debate about rape and abuse here has focused more and more on whether you actually say yes to sex, not so much if you say no. It makes sense in many ways. It's not always possible to say no. Maybe you're too afraid to say no, or maybe you're sleeping and can't say no.

As for what Assange did, I'll leave that to the court to decide.

Slashdot Top Deals

The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not "Eureka!" (I found it!) but "That's funny ..." -- Isaac Asimov

Working...