Comment Re:I'll second that. (Score 1) 605
Well, at least someone gets it.
To add to your well-written post, I believe the problem is that some people equate "high auto insurance risk" with "poor driver". As an example for those people, consider a race car driver. I'm quite sure the driver will have insurance on their personal vehicle(s). But does that mean they can just as easily get insurance on their race car? No. Is it because they suddenly become a much worse driver when they get into the race car? No. It's because they are in a much higher risk situation when racing.
To reinforce your final point for those who might not get it, driving ability is only one of many factors used to determine someone's risk. It's not an exact science and insurance companies don't have a magic crystal ball to determine when and who will make a claim and for how much. So they have to estimate it using factors that show a strong correlation with high risk. With all other things equal, being a bad driver correlates to being a higher risk, but the inverse is not necessarily true.