Comment Re:Aluminum-air (Score 1) 335
It feels like the aluminum is being consumed as fuel, like gasoline, but it's not.
Recycling the aluminum oxide back into aluminum is done using the same electrolytic process that is used when smelting aluminum (which is also oxide.)
It requires a great deal of electricity to do it. In that sense, the aluminum is just being used as a storage medium for electrical power, just like a regular battery, and can be expected to put the same kind of burden on the electrical supply.
I don't know how much energy ends up being wasted in this cycle either.
Similarly, hydrogen is best viewed as an energy storage medium, not as a alternative fuel.