Comment Re:While they were at it.... (Score 1) 165
I have not read "The Poetics" but...
I disagree with your interpretation of tragic irony in a modern sense. Every dictionary I can find either makes no mention of tragic irony or has a definition that makes it only a subset of dramatic irony in which the audience knows the truth of a situation but the characters in the drama (in this case a tragedy) do not. This would generally lead to an inappropriate response to a situation because (as I defined before with the first definition of irony) there is a disconnect between the truth and what people perceive (or say) causing some sort of problem. Almost all those dictionaries give Romeo's suicide as an example of tragic irony because, had he known that Juliet was faking it, he wouldn't have killed himself. But the audience knows the truth, thus exhibiting the incongruity between facts and what is being said/done. So even if Aristotle originally defined irony that way, that doesn't make it legit today. And if you take out the intervention of the gods, it really loses its teeth anyway.
That said, even with you definition of tragic irony, most of that stuff isn't ironic. For instance:
- Dying when you're 98: Actually pretty good. I doubt I'll live that long. The prior lottery win has no bearing on that being 24 years longer than the current American life expectancy.
- Fly in your wine? Wine contains sugars. Flies like sugar. Thereby flies like wine. It's not shit happening or irony, it's nature.
- Getting off death row: Unrealistic. If there were still proceedings going on they wouldn't kill the person, and if it was a presidential pardon or something, they probably knew when the person was going down and let it happen, rushing in just too late to make it look like they tried. If not, yes, it would be (by your definition) tragic irony, but it seems more contrived.
I could go on. Not taking good advice? Meeting married people? Having spoons?! Not irony, just life. Jove need not be referenced.