Comment Re:I agree with the recording industry (Score 1) 227
If they can provide evidence that the transfer has taken place, then they should take it to court. An ISP should have no hand in judging if evidence is legit. They are a service provider and their responsibilities are like those of a power company. Only if a court orders them to divulge the information from a murder suspect's smart electricity reader are they allowed to do so. You wouldn't call the power or water company to give them your statement and tell them to notify the police about the dead body and toaster you found in your bathtub, so why would you call on the ISP when you find someone "killing" your profits? When two rights are pitted against each other it's a matter for the courts resolve. I suspect this film studio just doesn't understand that in a society governed by law, you have to follow the proper procedures to minimize innocents being accused of wrongdoing.
Would the film studio shoulder the cost of damages payed out to the customer of the ISP after a court rules that the ISP harassed him/her repeatedly with false accusations based on weak evidence?
Would the film studio shoulder the cost of damages payed out to the customer of the ISP after a court rules that the ISP harassed him/her repeatedly with false accusations based on weak evidence?