Comment Re:Not surprised... (Score 1) 218
Obviously anecdotal evidence isn't much evidence at all, but I'll add my 2c CAD.
I have heard of, and had, both positive and negative experiences with Apple support. Almost all of my support issues have been at Apple Authorized Service Providers or Apple directly as we don't have an Apple store within anything close to a reasonable distance (the closest AASP was 6 hours away). But I've been fortunate to always be able to get things resolved with a few calls to Apple. And in the process I've managed to help get 2 substandard AASPs lose their status.
In one case, we had an out of warranty white Macbook about 2 years ago with the cracked case that was on recall. We brought it to the AASP, they replaced the case, but in so doing they damaged the trackpad. They refused to acknowledge it. I called Apple, they had had other complaints with these guys before (which they admitted!), they called the store as I was there and got my trackpad replaced. Next month they were no longer an AASP.
In a second case we bought a MBP off eBay with a dead logic board. I had researched the model and knew there was a well known issue with the GPU that caused this problem, and it was under recall. I got it, verified the issue with Apple's Hardware Diagnostics, and after talking to them on the phone I shipped it to the AASP for replacement. The AASP called us up to tell us that the hard drive was dead (confirmed by their propriety HD test suite, which was their primary business) and that we needed a replacement. I knew there wasn't a problem as I had tested it myself before shipping it off, so I told them just to ship it back. When I got it back it was rattling like crazy as they had left drive mounting parts out. I photographed it and sent it off to Apple. They called and apologized, shipped replacement parts, and a few months later when I checked the second shop had their AASP status pulled.
So I guess the moral of my story is that there are lots of guys in the service depts that are dishonest and/or inept, but Apple has always been good to me when I've dealt with them. That being said, their service quality does seem to be getting worse as now they no longer offer mail-in repair service up here like they used to one time, and if your new Mac has a manufacturing defect they won't just ship it back and replace it like they used to unless you're within the 1 week grace period of a new purchase. Instead, you have to bring it to an Apple store, which obviously isn't ideal.