Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:It was a farce... (Score 1) 384

The problem with PR is that it tends to come with party lists. Representatives become even more slavish to the party line than MPs are now, and independents don't stand a chance (particularly if you have a threshold). In principle, MPs are supposed to represent their constituents over the party.

I always admire the German Bundestagswahl system, with aspects of both. I believe the Scots use it in their parliament. I think the London Assembley operates on the same principle too.

Comment Re:It was a farce... (Score 1) 384

Exactly this.

I'm in Hammersmith, a notional marginal Labour/Conservative seat. I would rather have a Lib Dem MP, but they haven't a chance of winning, so I'll probably vote Tory because I'd rather have a Tory government than a Labour one. If we had STV I could codify this vote by voting Lib Dem, Tory, Labour*, or with PR I could vote Lib Dem knowing my vote would be counted. At the moment, voting Lib Dem means my vote has no impact on the governance of the country.

*I'd rather have Labour than UKIP, the BNP, the Greens, the English Democrats etc.

Comment Re:Yup (Score 1) 384

At the moment, we're just winding up Parliament before it is dissolved in a few days time. Any bill that pasts has to have the support of all three main parties, or it could easily be blocked in that time. Also it's a convention not to rush into law something which the next government will immediately chuck out, not least because it'll make the party that does it rather more unpopular.

So the Tories, and indeed the Liberal Democrats, bear some responsibility for allowing this bill to pass, unlike the rest of the year when there'd be nothing they could do to stop it.

Comment Re:There are no details (Score 1) 182

And it makes some pretty bold claims about those use cases...

Studies have shown that retail sales go up, productivity increases, and school grades improve thanks to natural indoor light. But the biggest gain is in the occupants’ health.

Is this true? I have a kneejerk reaction to "Studies have shown..."
I guess there may be some benefit to SADs cases*.

*Though I can never decide if it doesn't exist or if everyone in London has it. Check out the symptoms; "...some people experience a serious mood change when the seasons change. They may sleep too much, have little energy, and crave sweets and starchy foods. They may also feel depressed. Though symptoms can be severe, they usually clear up." [via Wiki]

Comment Re:Did you type this on a manual typewriter? (Score 1) 776

A good example for me is my dad driving up Remenham hill in a full car. This is a modern Mercedes automatic, and it shifts up too early, slowing the car down. Fortunately it also has manual paddles so you can correct this behaviour, but I'm glad my (tiny little 1.0l) VW Polo is manual. I can't imagine doing pulling out onto a dual carriage way in automatic.

Oh, to explain that last bit; here in England we have roads where traffic speed is 70mph that you can pull onto from a T-junction. No sliproad.

Comment Re:key (Score 1) 496

Yeah, those factors of four are really hard to compute in your head, right?

The calorie is loosely defined, but at 4.18something kJ/kcal it's more accurately defined than most people need to worry about. As someone else has already pointed out, it is defined as SI.

2500kcal is the UK Government's RDA for an adult male (compared to 2000kcal for a normal adult woman).

Comment Re:If I were Iran (Score 1) 319

As for nukes, they sometimes make sense as a deterrent, but almost never as a defense.

Quite so. Was talking to someone about Switzerland's policy of (heavily) armed neutrality the other day, they asked why Switzerland didn't have the bomb. After all, they have the wealth and the know-how. But what would they do with it? The only possible use for it wpuld hurt the Swiss as much as anyone else.

Slashdot Top Deals

All life evolves by the differential survival of replicating entities. -- Dawkins

Working...